# Site management processes and digital tools \| Mela

Source: https://www.mela.work/en/blog/construction-management-processes-digital-tools

Language: en

Practical guidance on construction-site management, Agile and Waterfall methods, key roles, documents, data and digital tools for better project control.

## Site management: practical notes on management processes and the digital tools that can help us

This article explains what to measure when assessing site management in a business, compares the Waterfall and Agile approaches, and examines the people involved in managing a site and the typical documents used.

Construction site management

Site management



## Types of construction site



To be more precise and useful, let us define the typical sites referred to in this article. We divide sites into 3 types and describe their characteristics.



We know that our division is unconventional, but it is simple and very useful for studying practical strategies for the processes and tools presented.



## Large sites, major works, infrastructure construction and complex sites



These sites are enormous, last for years and transform the urban and infrastructure context in which they are built. A new hospital, the refurbishment of a station and a new neighbourhood in a city centre are typical examples. These projects involve investment ranging from tens of millions of euros to billions. The rules and processes used to manage them are practically identical to those examined in this article, but the way they are implemented differs. These projects create operational and organisational structures responsible for specific processes, such as project management offices, quality assurance teams and cost controlling. These teams are dedicated to the project, meet continuously, share complex tools such as integrated BIM and project planning, and devote all their time to site management.



This type of site is often characterised by 2 key and distinctive figures: **a large client**, willing to invest significant sums and with highly structured and staffed internal processes, and **the general contractor**, able to take responsibility not only for the work but also for the administrative and management burden required by the client.



Many of the observations we make apply more to the subcontractors on these enormous sites than to the general contractor or the client for the entire project. However, we have often spoken with people responsible for these projects, who have consistently expressed feelings and needs very similar to those found on the sites we will call ordinary.



## Ordinary sites, refurbishments, small industrial works, houses, small infrastructure projects, etc.



My new bathroom, refurbishing my grandmother’s flat, the neighbours’ new house and the new 5-storey block being built opposite my home. These are the sites on which we will focus, ranging from a few thousand euros to a few million.



Lots and lots of sites where construction companies work alongside building-services contractors, window installers, gardeners, sheet-metal workers and… well, everyone\!



These are the sites covered by this article and the ones on which we will focus. The observations also apply to the others, with a few adaptations.



## Small works, maintenance, mobile sites and very short-duration sites



These are very small, fast and sometimes mobile sites. We often do not even call them sites because they have no red safety netting around them, no site sign with expired dates and no tower cranes: work started this morning and is already finished by midday\!



The maintenance of our cities—water mains, roads and signs—as well as our homes—boilers, leaks and shutters—falls into this category; indeed, these are its main examples.



These are construction sites too and follow the same principles and rules as the others, with a few specific features relating to logistics and safety.



## What should I measure to assess the quality of site management in my business?



## What are the main objectives of site management?



1. **Complete the work**, and do it well and all the way through. It may sound obvious, but an unfinished project is the greatest possible failure for a site.
2. Do it **while respecting people and the environment**, both in terms of safety and sustainability.
3. **Build an economic profit** around the site’s activities. This is not always a business profit, but that is what we will focus on here.



This article will not explore safety and environmental aspects of site management in depth. These are two specific and important subjects that deserve separate treatment and further analysis.



We are discussing how to complete the work while generating an economic profit. We will see that managing a site correctly often not only delivers these results but also has a positive impact on site safety and sustainability.



## Which variables have the greatest impact on site profit?



We have defined 2 main objectives: **complete the work and generate an economic profit**. We are now asking which variables have the greatest impact on these aspects and what puts them most at risk.



The left-hand column of the table lists the main variables that affect the success of a site.



We ask this question at every site-management training event and have now collected responses from several thousand participants. In the right-hand column, you will find an indication of how many people, on average, believe that each variable has a clear impact on site success: HIGH, where almost all participants identify a strong correlation; MEDIUM, where around 50% identify it; and LOW, where fewer than 20% identify it and very few take action to influence it.

| What affects site profit? | Awareness among construction professionals |
| --- | --- |
| 1️⃣ Materials, quality, cost and availability | 🟢 High This is the variable that most concerns construction-sector stakeholders. The perception was reinforced by the inflationary trends seen in 2021 and 2022. |
| 2️⃣ Hire and services | 🟢 High This is very similar to the consideration linked to materials: these are direct costs clearly connected to the site. |
| 3️⃣ Labour, cost, productivity and availability | 🟢 High Everyone has a clear perception of the cost of labour and the cost of knowledge. |
| 4️⃣ Design, completeness and feasibility | 🟡 Medium This variable is often mentioned, but there is a perception that the outcome was already decided before the site phase and that, during construction, people can only appreciate the consequences. |
| 5️⃣ Time—meaning costs caused by delays | 🟢 High When work takes longer, my costs increase because of additional hires, extra hours and so on. |
| 6️⃣ Time—meaning lost production caused by delays | 🔴 Low This is probably the least appreciated variable in construction. Delays are treated as endemic and the cost of lost production is almost never assessed. |
| 7️⃣ Site logistics | 🟢 High Construction professionals generally have a good understanding of the costs associated with transport and storage, partly because this is a physical feature of a site: materials are heavy and take up a lot of space. |
| 8️⃣ Information availability | 🔴 Low People rarely connect information with site costs. Occasionally, someone mentions site-management costs as staff costs for accounting and administrative work. The financial value of having information available when making operational decisions is almost never assessed. |
| 9️⃣ Communication between stakeholders, collaboration and planning | 🟡 Medium Communication between site stakeholders, their coordination and resource planning are seen as natural processes and are rarely perceived as levers for increasing site profit or reducing costs. One example concerns errors and rework. |
| 🔟 Errors and rework | 🟡 Medium Everyone knows that errors cost money, but they are rarely perceived as an influenceable variable. Yet construction-sector estimates indicate a loss between 5 and 10% of the total project cost. |

## The concept of lost production in site management



If a washing-machine production line breaks down, the plant manager’s first thought is the **cost of lost production**. Anyone who has visited a modern manufacturing production line will have noticed colour screens showing the productivity of the entire line over time compared with its theoretical maximum. I could have produced 10 washing machines in the last hour, but I produced 9; my productivity index is 90%—still green. If I produced 7, my productivity index would be 70%—now red and not a good sign—and my main concern would be the loss of 30%: the cost of lost production.



We asked participants in our courses to estimate the average delay on their sites. The first thing that stands out is that nobody is surprised by the question: it is normal for a site to be late\! The average estimated delay is between 50% and 100% of the planned time. It is common to plan to complete a site in one year and instead take 18 months. When we ask whether this delay affects site costs, many mention extended hire periods or unplanned extra hours, but very few identify lost production—being unable to work on the next site—as a cost to consider. Yet even basic calculations show that a 50% delay in delivering a site represents a reduction in revenue, or an increase in costs, of 30%. This is compounded by the cash-flow issue, which is already more widely recognised in construction: the later I deliver the work, the later I get paid.



## The importance of data in site management—Those who invest in innovation and digitalisation complete sites early



What do large companies do to improve site management?



[This research published by KPMG in 2019](https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2019/04/global-construction-survey-2019.pdf) analysed 155 large companies active in construction worldwide and divided them into 3 categories according to their ability to innovate: Innovative Leaders, Followers and Behind the Curve.



The following chart shows how the 3 categories invest in site-management technologies.



The main technologies in which the construction sector is investing are **BIM, Data & Analytics, Integrated Project Management and Mobile Applications**. These technologies alone account for more than 50% of total investment.



The Innovative Leaders also invest consistently in all these technologies: 9 out of 10 have implemented BIM, 8 out of 10 have implemented digital systems for collecting and managing site data, and 8 out of 10 have digital project-management systems.

Construction site management

The obvious question is: do the Innovative Leaders, which invest so heavily in digital site management, achieve different results from those further behind in digitalisation?



The answer is yes\!



The same research provides the answer: **Innovative Leaders complete 66% of sites at least 10% early**—producing more than planned—and therefore increase site revenue by a similar amount.



## Site management—two approaches compared: Waterfall or Agile?



## What are the stages of effective site management?



A site can be divided into 4 logical stages:



- **Design**


- **Planning and preparation**


- **Construction**


- **Final accounting**



These 4 stages are presented in a logical sequence and do not necessarily follow one another in a rigid timetable. In fact, modern site-management concepts require continuous feedback cycles to evolve from a **Waterfall** view of site management to a **more Agile view** of the problem.



## How site management works in Waterfall processes



### Design in great detail



This approach is based on designers’ ability to draw and **predict almost all the variables we will face during construction**. Typical statements include the need to design more and better and to take the technical study’s analysis to a very high level of detail.



This detailed design forces us to ask questions about the work’s feasibility and conflicts between disciplines—civil, mechanical, electrical and so on—and encourages us to design the site’s execution phase, logistics and interfaces.



This effort has positive effects on the final result by preventing many of the problems that would otherwise affect the execution phase.



### The execution phase as the implementation of instructions



After such detailed planning, execution is expected to be a simple matter of “following instructions”. Naturally, it never is, and 3 factors particularly disrupt this perfect plan:



- **Changes** (because the available material has changed or the client has changed their mind)


- **Interfaces** (the window installers come today rather than next week)


- **Details** we missed or errors (in design or construction)



Anyone who has managed sites knows that each of these disruptions starts as a small pebble and soon becomes an avalanche. During planning, we assumed that the results achieved in the previous phase would form the basis for the next work. Changes, the impossibility of carrying something out or errors alter those foundations and make our plan fail.



Note: the worst situation is when the detailed plan is embedded in the project’s contractual structure: we have just created the perfect conditions for a huge amount of litigation.



## How the Agile approach is applied to site management



Can we plan a project without changes, interfaces and errors? In the history of humanity, no such project has ever existed.



Does this mean that every project is destined to end with delays, budget overruns and disputes? We do not think so\!



The Agile approach can help us **manage the site’s most problematic events—changes, interfaces and errors—without turning them into destructive avalanches**. The following chart helps compare the characteristics of Agile site management with the Waterfall process.

Construction site management

The key is to define the project plan while recognising that it must adapt to the conditions encountered as the site evolves, and to create processes able to coordinate site stakeholders so that they continue to implement one coordinated plan even while it evolves.



What are the key points for implementing Agile on site?



1. Site control room—**Information sharing**
2. **Review of the execution plan** and continuous adjustment
3. The project itself is Agile—**Continuous feedback between builder and designer**
4. **Agile procurement process**



WARNING: it is not possible to add Agile as an exception-management layer to Waterfall\! This is even more dangerous and inefficient in site-management environments where communication and collaboration are particularly structured and regulated. A typical example could be a public contract where the approach was not defined from the contractual stages onwards.



### Agile, information sharing on site and the site control room



Who controls the site? Who is the general in command? In reality, nobody\! Whichever management process you choose, a site does not follow the orders of a single general.



A site is a complex system in which different parties collaborate to complete the work. These parties operate in environments that are separate from one another—the window supplier, the electrician and the new owner of flat 5—and therefore tend to move randomly. The independent forces influencing the actions of the different stakeholders are stronger than any order issued by a general in charge.



To make these stakeholders move in a coordinated way towards completing the work, we must change the forces acting on each part so that they behave as much as possible like a coherent system. An experienced site manager will create a control room where stakeholders can meet, gather information about the system’s progress and decide how to contribute, rather than simply issuing orders.



To do this, they need a physical place—or, better still, a **DIGITAL** one—to share information about progress, logistics, procurement and design: a genuine site control room.



*[In this article](/en/blog/construction-4-0-managing-the-construction-site-in-2021) you will find an entertaining and comprehensive description of the digital technologies affecting site management and construction in general.*



*We recommend [this interesting article](/en/blog/the-role-of-the-project-director), in which a highly experienced Works Director analyses the importance of communication and digital technologies for site success.*



In this way, the different stakeholders have access to a shared information archive that enables them to:



- find the simplest way to reach the objective


- meet the other stakeholders and discuss matters with them


- be informed quickly about what is happening


- help others so that they can help them in turn



Without this foundation, it is impossible to use an Agile site-management process.



### Continuously changing the site execution plan—Correcting problems as early as possible and improving the execution plan



This is one of the most difficult points to implement because precise, strict planning allows resources to be allocated well in advance and their use to be optimised. This produces excellent results in contracting terms and allows significant savings. That is why the chimera of the perfect plan has taken us so far without ever being achieved.



Changing the plan continuously conflicts with the principle of resource optimisation.



However, resource allocation is optimal only while we follow the original plan. As soon as it changes—because of changes, interfaces or errors—unprepared teams risk serious problems and deadlock.



Our advice is to expect the plan to change and accept that nobody can define the actual configuration at the execution stage in advance. Napoleon maintained that every battle plan was excellent until the first cannonball; sites are very similar.



It is therefore useful to create a culture that brings many warning signals to light and ensures that they reach the control room. With an effective collaborative system, fictitious problems are quickly discarded, while issues that could become avalanches are addressed promptly, while they are still handfuls of stones. In an Agile process, a higher cost for solving problems is expected in the initial phase in order to avoid major avalanches later.

Construction site management

A key point is to incorporate flexibility from the tender and contracting stage. This may sound strange to those used to strict instructions from Works Directors, but we increasingly see time-related changes that are not caused by defaulting contractors but by client requests and circumstances outside the company’s control. In these uncertain contexts, **flexibility is an important value**, and accepting a small amount of initial inefficiency can help ensure that the goal is reached.



### The project itself is Agile—Continuous feedback between builder, designer and client



Traditional project development produces a large amount of documentation before, during and after delivery of the final product.



The Agile approach, which originated in the software industry, contrasts with the traditional model by prioritising the product and its characteristics over the related documentation, which consumes significant time and resources.

Untitled construction site management graphic

The red curve describes the traditional process: folders of documents travel from the client—the requirements—to the design office—the design—and then to the builders, where they are converted into construction designs, only to discover that they will still be changed and rewritten on site.



The green curve instead imagines a real or virtual room where the client, designer and builder continuously discuss the design. Through increasingly detailed iterations, they build a feasible project that is actually built. The execution phase is therefore almost parallel to the design phase.



In this respect, using integrated BIM design tools that minimise the number of “side” documents can help.



### Agile procurement process



Implementing the approaches described above must transform the way we think about project procurement strategy. We have seen how contracts that align the interests of the main site stakeholders—client, Works Director and builder—make Agile working methods easier to introduce. However, this process is extremely difficult from a procurement perspective.



In particular, two forces conflict:



- To align interests and adopt Agile methods, I must create an ecosystem between suppliers and the client: they must know one another, share values and create an environment of trust


- In the long term, this creates closed ecosystems that damage the competitiveness of the global construction system



It is difficult but not impossible, and technology can help.



### Contracts must shift control mechanisms from results to methods: they must promote transparency



Traditionally, the client has imposed extensive controls on the supplier’s results, placing the two parties on opposite sides of the barricade. In an exaggerated, tragicomic version, the client searches for errors and applies penalties, while the supplier tries to prevent any observation that could lead to errors and penalties—all while attempting to complete the work. Contracts regulate this behaviour by allowing the supplier to provide limited information and the client to apply penalties whenever that information reveals problems.



To reverse this situation, it is necessary to **build a relationship of trust based on collaboration and transparency**. This is why the site control room matters: people meet there and information is exchanged in large quantities through a continuous flow.



In this respect, adopting digital tools dedicated to collaboration and transparency is essential.



*[This article](/en/blog/italian-work-progress-sal-procurement-code-2023) contains ideas on how the contractor’s Site Manager and the Works Director can use technology to build trust and transparency for mutual benefit.*



Put simply, contracts should apply larger penalties for information that is not shared or is concealed during the process, by either party, than for the final results achieved.



## Who are the main people involved in site management?



## The client



We often forget that the person who pays and ultimately needs to be satisfied is the client. The client is usually seen as a nuisance in site management rather than as a resource.



In reality, the client is essential when managing problematic events that undermine the Waterfall approach and is an extremely important resource when redefining the scope under an Agile approach.



It is also important never to forget that the client awards contracts to all the other stakeholders: the designer, builder and assurance roles, including the DL and CSE.



Synonyms and people performing this function: Client, contracting authority, awarding authority, Responsabile Unico del Procedimento (RUP)



## The designer



This is the professional appointed by the client who turns the client’s needs into a feasible technical design. This person is essential for choosing the technical solutions used to complete the work. By imagining the finished work, the designer must also imagine its feasibility and “buildability”: by designing the work, they are also defining the site.



Synonyms and people performing this function: Design office, technical office that designed the work



## The builder



This is the company that carries out the work. There may be one company or several, each responsible for a specific part. The company has professionals working on site who physically complete the work. They are usually coordinated within a structure of varying complexity, but there is at least one person responsible for the activities: the Site Manager.



Synonyms and people performing this function: Contractor, construction company, Site Manager, Project Manager, site surveyor, construction surveyor, company



## The Works Director



This is the professional appointed by the client who guarantees that the design is carried out correctly, respecting the timescales and financial obligations established in the contracts. This is one of the key roles in the successful execution of the work.



*[In this article](/en/blog/construction-project-director-report-templates) you will find an interesting analysis of the processes and methods used by the Works Director from a site-digitalisation perspective.*



Synonyms and people performing this function: Works Direction Office, Works Director’s Assistant, DL



## The CSE



The CSE, Coordinatore per la Sicurezza in fase di Esecuzione, is the professional who coordinates safety matters on the client’s behalf. The CSE is the point of reference for all site stakeholders on safety.



*[In this article](/en/blog/safety-coordinator-requirements-ciani-report-templates) you will find a detailed guide to carrying out the CSE’s activities and integrating them with digital tools. We also refer you to the very detailed and practical flowchart.*



## What are the typical documents used in site management?



This section should briefly return to the purpose of this article, which focuses on medium-sized and small sites. The documentary workload can vary considerably from case to case.



We also want to return to the concept of Agile design mentioned above: we will follow the green path, not the red one\!



## The design



The design consists of the drawings, documents, calculations and checks that describe the work.



Here is a list of the designs, or design sections, that are often discussed.

| no. | Design stages | Specialist involved |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Instrumental planimetric and altimetric survey (levels, boundaries, distances…) | Designer |
| 2 | Preliminary design (Concept, Rendering, Outline study) | Designer / Designer |
| 3 | Final design for planning/building authorisation | Designer |
| 4 | Detailed, buildable design (with bill of quantities and prices) | Designer |
| 5 | Earthquake-resistant structural design (reinforced concrete and seismic risk class) | Structural engineer |
| 6 | Geological and geotechnical design (with penetration tests) | Geologist |
| 7 | Environmental design / Excavated earth and rock (with ARPAV declaration of use) | Geologist |
| 8 | Chemical and physical analysis of soil / waste | Accredited laboratory |
| 9 | Electrical installation design | Electrical-services designer |
| 10 | Water, heating and sanitary installation design | Building-services engineer |
| 11 | Energy design / Thermal insulation / Energy class | Building-services engineer |
| 12 | Acoustic insulation design (with instrumental tests) | Sound technician |
| 13 | Fire-prevention design (Fire Brigade submission) | Fire-prevention technician |
| 14 | PSC—Safety and Coordination Plan | CSP |
| 15 | As Built | Builder |

For each of these designs, the principle of modular detail applies: how detailed should the design be in relation to the site’s progress?



The earlier discussion of Waterfall and Agile sites requires us to consider the purpose of each design document and the level of detail required.



## Italian local-authority authorisations



Here is a list of authorisations certifying that whoever manages the local planning rules in the area of our site knows about the site and, where necessary, has granted permission to proceed.



However, one of these documents may not be sufficient to start work. This depends on the specific site, its complexity, its impact on the environment, its location and the relevant constraints, such as heritage and historic restrictions.



The client and the project designer decide which authorisation to request for the work. We identify 3 possible application levels:



1. **Permesso di costruire**
2. **SCIA**
3. **CILA**



The level of documentation submitted and the checks carried out by the technicians decrease from 1 to 3.



### Permesso di costruire—New construction or major alteration



This is an authorisation issued by the Comune for new construction or substantial refurbishment that significantly changes the building from its original condition. This also includes work involving changes to volume, form or intended use.



### Segnalazione certificata di inizio attività (SCIA)—Major extraordinary maintenance



SCIA is required for extraordinary maintenance, restoration or conservation work. This authorisation replaced the former DIA (Denuncia di Inizio Attività) and must be submitted to the relevant Comune. In some cases, the local building regulations determine whether work requires SCIA or a Permesso di Costruire.



### Comunicazione di Inizio Lavori Asseverata (CILA)—Minor extraordinary maintenance



CILA, or Comunicazione di Inizio Lavori Asseverata, is the authorisation needed to refurbish a building through minor extraordinary maintenance. It is mandatory when the work does not affect the building’s structural parts. Because this concerns less substantial work, the technician must certify its compliance with all applicable rules.



## The bill of quantities



Like a recipe, the bill of quantities is the document stating which materials, people and activities are needed to complete a design.



*[See this article](/en/blog/what-is-the-bill-of-quantities) for a detailed description of this document and the related processes.*



### Bill of quantities and BIM



Increasingly, the bill of quantities is not created manually by the technician but extracted semi-automatically from the BIM design. This undoubtedly speeds up quantity calculations and makes bills more accurate.



On the other hand, we must be aware of the super-bill phenomenon: a bill that is increasingly precise and detailed but incomprehensible to people and extremely difficult to contract. We have seen bills running from 500 pages to 4.



## Contractual and accounting management of the site



### Construction contracts



We are now about to complete the work and must appoint the company or companies and the office or offices that will act as builder and controller (DL and CSE). We can use tenders or direct awards: in private sites, trust and personal relationships play an important role in deciding who carries out the work; public works have procedures designed to make the award as objective as possible, with rules set by the procurement code.



A document that the client and company should never neglect to prepare is the construction contract. It should include at least the following:



- The client


- The builder, including the subcontracting and services structure where applicable


- The scope of work and related bill of quantities


- The financial offer


- The project timetable



### The site diary



Put simply, [the site diary](/en/blog/construction-logbook-completed-example) is the work diary: the story of how the work was carried out.



There must be one single story, digital, rich in photographs and detail, and available in the site control room. Anything that does not meet these rules is somewhat outdated.



### Measurement books, accounting register and SAL



The work has finally started and we can measure production using measurement books. Their financial valuation and integration over time produce the accounting register, which, according to the milestones established in the contract, allows us to prepare the [SAL](/en/blog/italian-work-progress-sal-procurement-code-2023).



## The builder must keep a long list of documents on site



This list indicates the documents that the builder and contractors must have on site. As always, it is not exhaustive but represents a typical medium-sized site.



- Certificate of registration with the chamber of commerce and valid DURC


- Declaration that the company is not subject to disqualification measures


- Contracts and UNILAV


- Designations, appointments and delegations of company safety roles:


- Appointment of RSPP (Responsabile dei Servizi di Prevenzione e Protezione)


- Appointment of competent doctor


- Appointment of RLS (Workers’ Safety Representatives) and election minutes


- Appointment of the works supervisor


- Appointment of the first-aid officer


- Appointment of the fire-safety officer


- Training certificate for the employer performing RSPP duties


- First-aid officers’ certificate (three-year renewal)


- Fire-safety officers’ certificate (three-year renewal)


- RLS training certificate or, alternatively, appointment of RLST


- 16-hour worker training and information certificate


- Training and authorisation certificate for operators of equipment requiring specific authorisation, such as aerial platforms, category 3 PPE, earthmoving machinery and asbestos removal equipment


- Accident register


- Workers’ medical fitness certificates


- Declaration of conformity for the site electrical and earthing systems, with the related transmission form


- Declarations of conformity and operating and maintenance manuals for machinery and equipment


- Records confirming delivery of PPE to workers


- For scaffolding


- PIMUS—for scaffolding where required


- Ministry authorisation booklet


- Scaffolding design


- Calculation report



The importance of a digital solution is immediately clear if these documents are to be available on site and kept up to date.

## Article video
