# Construction estimates: how to prepare and optimise \| Mela

Source: https://www.mela.work/en/blog/construction-quote-purpose-preparation-optimization

Language: en

A practical guide to preparing construction and building-services estimates, with examples, contract models, risk management and cost control.

## Construction estimate: what it is for, how to prepare it and how to optimise the process

A practical guide to preparing construction and building-services estimates, with practical examples and explanations of the principles and processes to adopt.

Construction estimate

Construction estimate



## What is a construction estimate?



A construction estimate is a document listing the work to be carried out, its quantities and the associated cost.



It is therefore a table in which each row corresponds to an activity to be carried out, with a quantity and price. The sum of the price of each row defines the total cost of the work.



Preparing this document activates 3 concurrent processes:



**1. WHAT?**



Define the work plan: the sequence of events which, starting from the current situation, will allow me to reach the final objective.



**2. HOW MUCH?**



Quantify the work, measure, draw and calculate.



**3. THE COST?**



Establish the cost of each estimate item.



It goes without saying that, when defining the work—what needs to be done—some requests may concern the supply of materials. This does not change the essence of the estimate, only the object to be delivered; indeed, it is easy to see how an estimate covering only material supplies is normal when the material purchasing processes are separated from the services.



Here is an example of a construction estimate in Excel:

Bathroom renovation estimate

So far, nothing could be simpler, but things are about to get more interesting: let us add a little spice.



### Example of an estimate using an application dedicated to site management



In this case, the [**software**](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsmSmnF9k3M) I am using will have a first page for entering items—which will probably be taken automatically from a library—a second summary page, and probably the option to export the estimate so it can be sent to the client.

Construction estimating software

The estimate summary screen immediately highlights the relationship between the estimate and site costs. By managing [daily reports](/en/blog/work-report-definition-company-implementation) and tracking site costs in the same app, I can immediately understand where I am making money and where I am losing it.

Estimate

Finally, the estimate can be printed and sent to the client. It is also interesting that the client can [sign the estimate](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_s6K_yLLPYA) directly in the app to accept it.

Screenshot3

## Why prepare a construction estimate? The real objective is risk management



Instinctively, we think of an estimate as a mechanism for establishing the cost of a project. There is indeed an economic aspect: will I be able to pay for the work? How much money do I need to set aside? However, this is only one way of summarising a broader concept that includes client satisfaction, the contractor’s remuneration and the sustainability of the work—economic, environmental, social and so on.



Whenever work begins, an agreement is made between a client and a supplier, and the estimate is at the heart of that agreement. In this sense, a well-prepared estimate is one that can **minimise conflicts between the parties and distribute the risk of carrying out the work fairly.**



Yes, you read that correctly: a well-prepared estimate is not one that eliminates risk for the client. Let us see why.



### What types of estimate are there, and how are they linked to the project’s bill of quantities?



Let us define the 3 contractual structures—the columns in the table below—typically used to carry out a project, and analyse their main characteristics and relationships with the different aspects of the problem—the table rows.

| Criterion | Service-based contracts – The client coordinates the work | Measured-work contracts – The client monitors progress | Turnkey contract – The client arrives when the work is finished |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The client’s intention | The client buys services and materials separately and coordinates the execution of the work. | The client defines a list of work to be carried out and measures the supplier’s progress against it. | The client defines the scope of the work and passively waits for it to be completed. |
| The estimate | There is no genuine estimate of the work. Instead, there is a price list for services, such as the hourly cost of labour. | The estimate is based on the list of work to be carried out, which, completed one item after another, results in the execution of the entire project. | The estimate is based on a single item representing the work as a whole. |
| How materials are managed | The client buys all the materials. | It depends on how each estimate item is managed. | The supplier buys all the materials. |
| Managing changes | The client can decide on every change independently. | The parties discuss and manage changes together. | The client cannot request changes because they only manage final acceptance of the work. |
| Who assumes the risk of carrying out the work | The client assumes most of the risk. The only risk remaining with the supplier concerns the client’s financial soundness. | Risk is balanced between supplier and client. | The supplier bears all the risk. The only risk remaining with the client concerns the supplier’s ability to complete the work. |

From a risk perspective, we can see a shift depending on the contractual structure adopted.

Screenshot 2023 09 08 at 11 45 41

*The expert’s reflection*



- *Almost no project is managed according to a single contractual structure; a combination of service-based, measured-work and turnkey work is generally assigned according to the circumstances*


- *Measured-work contracts tend to distribute risk more fairly between client and supplier*


- *No contractual structure can eliminate risk for either the client or the supplier*



In the 3 cases analysed above, the construction estimate takes different forms:



- Under a service-based contract, it becomes more of a **price list** defining the hourly cost of personnel, the unit cost of materials and so on.


- Under a measured-work contract, the price list evolves by combining **the cost of the work**—and sometimes the materials—into the unit price of the work completed, such as flooring per square metre. Here, the estimate takes the classic form of a table with descriptions, measurements and costs.


- Under a turnkey contract, the estimate collapses into a single row that **defines the entire project.**



It becomes clear that **the different forms of contract reflect different attitudes to risk**: an experienced client may prefer full control over the work, accepting greater exposure to risk, while an entirely external client may prefer to play no role in controlling the work and leave the entire matter to the supplier.



Clearly, clients with the skills to manage work are scarce—it could hardly be otherwise—and so the client must generally rely on the supplier, transferring decision-making power and the associated risks to them. In doing so, the client loses control of the work and adopts various strategies to achieve the desired result nevertheless.



*The expert’s reflection*



- *It is always difficult to draw a clear line between defining the desired result precisely and not interfering with the free choices of the supplier and professional carrying out the work. In reality, every form of contract requires a strong commitment to dialogue, discussion and transparency to achieve excellent results. [This](/en/blog/construction-management-processes-digital-tools) [*article on introducing AGILE construction sites and its benefits in terms of results*](/en/blog/construction-management-processes-digital-tools) explains it.*



### Beware of overly detailed bills of quantities and impossible estimates



The main tool used to manage a measured-work contract is the [bill of quantities](/en/blog/what-is-the-bill-of-quantities), that is, the list of activities and work to be carried out.



The average number of bill-of-quantity items has increased over time, starting with overly sparse bills—‘I want to build a house’—and progressing to excessively detailed bills, creating documents that are impossible for the human mind to manage.



Indeed, partly thanks to the arrival of software for designing projects and semi-automatic generation of bills of quantities, these documents have become increasingly long and complex.



This is a client-driven process. Using internal technical departments or external professional practices, the client structures the bill of quantities with ever greater precision, remembering that anything absent from the bill of quantities and the related estimate is always used by the supplier as room for manoeuvre in which the client feels vulnerable. However, beware: **this trend brings management costs that can harm the success of the entire project.**



*The expert’s reflection*



- *My father told me that in the 50s entire houses were built starting with a handshake: no bill of quantities, no drawings and no contract. There was no risk management and, consequently, enormous risks for completing the work and for the survival of the company. Many companies went bankrupt.*


- *This changed over time, and the longest bill of quantities I have ever seen was 600 pages A4. Such a long bill requires the establishment of a project management office, a significant cost to be dedicated to managing the work and considered during the tender stage.*


- *The bill of quantities for a project carried out without a project management office must be understandable and controllable by one person, within the reach of the human brain: a few pages.*



Another problem linked to the detail of bills of quantities is **the risk of contradiction** that arises as detail increases.



By specifying the materials to be used and the work stages ever more precisely, we risk running into intrinsic contradictions—conflicts between different parts of the design—and extrinsic contradictions—caused by external factors such as the market availability of a particular material.



These contradictions cost the client both in the initial effort required to write the bill and through errors during execution—errors for which the supplier cannot be held responsible because they were caused by the bill of quantities.



## How can construction estimates be optimised?



Construction estimates are often considered in terms of profit or the client’s cost. These parameters are certainly fundamental, but they are not the only ones to consider.



*The expert’s reflection*



- *We are often told that the price of an estimate is not what the client will base their choice on. True. But remember: in the end, it is always the sum that makes the total\!*



Issuing estimates is a process that must be structured. There are too many requests for estimates and far fewer jobs: this is a fact that applies to everyone. However, this should not discourage us from managing every request as well as possible, creating a channel of understanding with the client that will allow us to win the work with the right level of risk.



Many of the same considerations arise repeatedly, and having clear ideas in advance speeds up and simplifies the process.



### Build an estimate through successive stages of precision



Clients request estimates in at least two different stages:



- **Budget estimate.** They ask how much a project will cost to understand whether they have the money to carry it out.


- **Commercial estimate** to award a contract. In this case, the client is genuinely looking for someone to do the work and wants to award a contract.



Knowing this information is essential to understanding the level of detail at which we should respond.



*The expert’s reflection*



- *Do not refuse to provide a budget estimate: whoever helps the client build the budget is in pole position when the estimate is prepared.*


- *When a client requests a budget estimate, they often do not yet know the true scale of the work. They are studying the problem through successive stages of approximation: from very approximate to more precise.*


- *Helping the client frame the problem and study its cost also brings them closer to our estimating model* and therefore to our rules for managing risk.


- *Do not do the calculations during this stage; provide the client with information that helps them do the calculations.*



### Have estimate templates



The first thing to do is have a standard estimate template, one that allows you to write the agreement with the client using language familiar to you.



This standard template starts with a structured list of services you can provide and for which you know how to give prices.



From this, you can derive around ten standard estimates representing the 80% of the work you are asked to price. Issuing an estimate from these templates should require very little effort.



Sometimes clients will ask us to follow their bill of quantities and reproduce the estimate according to its items. This is a negotiation between you and the client and can be very difficult to win in public procurement, but, especially in private work, you have options.



1. **The final price\!** The first point is that, by rewriting the estimate according to the items familiar to you, you will be able to optimise your commercial offer.
2. **The supply strategy.** You will be able to state precisely what you can do directly, what you subcontract and what, unfortunately, you cannot do—minimise these points because they are highly damaging to the client’s final choice.



### Have a standardised method for calculating prices



Start with your 10 pre-prepared estimate templates, structured in tables. They may be paper tables that we photocopy and modify by hand each time—which is somewhat primitive—or Excel sheets for automating some calculations, or specific applications for estimating on construction sites. All methods are acceptable provided they allow us to create estimates within a few minutes.



### Have standardised, short and clear attachments



Time is precious for suppliers and clients alike. With this in mind, it is important to minimise the information we send with an estimate. We should include the information we consider important, stripping away all the embellishments we are accustomed to attaching—pages and pages of brochures, repeated information and exclusions from the work and supplies.



Many of the documents we attach are also technical and contain abbreviations and descriptions understood only by professionals. The client may not be able to understand the nuances, and every unclear or misunderstood page leaves a negative impression. A long, difficult-to-read estimate is perceived by the client as a lawyers’ trap in which we have said everything and its opposite.



Added to this is the effort the client must make to understand the estimate: people’s attention span is becoming ever shorter. This is true on TikTok and Instagram, but it is also true of our estimates.



### Mistakes to avoid in an estimate



1. Hiding the total cost among a thousand pieces of information. A well-prepared estimate should begin with a summary page explaining what can be done, what cannot be done, when we are ready to carry out the work and how much it will cost—clearly and immediately. This creates trust in the client relationship.
2. Leaving unpriced parts of the work without highlighting this to the client. If we cannot provide the complete solution, we should help the client build the complete action plan. The client does not want to buy our service; they want to complete the project, and our services are only part of it.
3. Delivering an estimate with only measured prices and failing to state the total expenditure.
4. Not being clear about the client’s objective. Asking questions about the client’s intentions helps us provide context and understand the real question we need to answer. Exploring the client’s timings, plans and external constraints helps us give a coherent response that reassures the client without wasting time. Sometimes an answer that is too detailed at a preliminary or budget stage also damages our image.
5. Failing to consider the completion times and the overall plan. Timing is fundamental and can turn good answers into unacceptable ones.



### Standardised process for creating an estimate for a construction site

Construction estimate: what it is for, how to prepare it and how to optimise the process 1

## Did you make or lose money on that job? How to use the estimate together with construction-site cost control



Profit, loss or, worse still, failure to collect some or all of the payment for the work are clear evidence of the quality of the estimate. It is even better if, after working for us once, the client comes back and becomes a regular client. In short, well-prepared estimates lay the foundations for the long-term sustainability of the business.



Often, however, we do not know precisely or promptly whether we made or lost money while carrying out a job. We want to highlight 2 problems: one concerns the accuracy of the calculation of a job’s profit, and the second concerns how promptly this information becomes available—the ‘when’.



*The expert’s reflection*



- *Project managers who are afraid of losing money begin to protect themselves in every site-related question and decision, making the work difficult and eventually bringing it to a halt. A strong atmosphere of distrust develops, and the possibility of the project failing becomes increasingly high.*


- *On the other hand, we need a rapid and realistic, even if approximate, understanding of how the site accounts are evolving; otherwise, we risk causing the company carrying out the work to fail.*



It therefore becomes clear that I must establish a [cost-control](/en/blog/construction-app-one-click-cost-control#editorial-2881-en-2-2-construction-site-app-with-mela-you-immediately-record-emp) process that guarantees at least two characteristics:



1. **It must be real time**, while the work is taking place.
2. **It must be able to link costs to estimate items.**



We recommend reading this in-depth guide to discover how to set up a construction-site cost-control process that meets these characteristics:



### How to compare construction-site costs automatically with estimate items



When I have control over site costs, I should be able to compare them with the work estimate. The question I ask is not only how much I am spending, but also where I am spending it.



The figure below shows a real case of cost progress for the various estimate items: it can be seen that general masonry activities have exceeded the initial expenditure estimate.

Construction estimate

This type of analysis is possible only through the **digitalisation of cost-control processes**, daily site reports and other cost items.



### But what can we do when we discover an estimate item on which we are losing money?



Do not panic: losing money on one estimate item is not serious if the site as a whole is generating the expected profit. However, we can ask why this is happening and assess whether or not to involve the client in the discussion.



As we said at the beginning, the estimate is a risk-management document. Depending on the structure adopted, informing the client about the items causing a loss can be a tool for managing and mitigating project risk. Do not overdo it, however, or we will undermine the relationship of trust and the long-term sustainability of the business.



*The expert’s reflection*



- *Sometimes it is better to accept a loss than to lose face\!*


- *In some cases, there are estimate items that we know will make a loss, but we were forced by the client or the opportunity to provide that quotation.*


- *Always use these lessons to improve your next estimate\!*
