# SCIA in Sanatoria: how to regularise building discrepancies \| Mela

Source: https://www.mela.work/en/blog/italian-scia-regularization-guide

Language: en

A practical guide to SCIA in sanatoria: requirements, double compliance, sanctions, timings and the documents needed to regularise building discrepancies.

## Guide to SCIA in Sanatoria: how to regularise building discrepancies

The aim of this article is to provide a clear and detailed overview of SCIA in sanatoria, making the information needed accessible to those working in the construction sector or to property owners who need to use this procedure to regularise certain works. We will analyse the relevant legal provisions, offering practical explanations and operational advice for approaching the procedure safely, with the aim of developing a thorough understanding of this legal instrument and its potential.

SCIA in sanatoria: how to remedy building abuses

SCIA in sanatoria: how to remedy building abuses



**Contents:**



## 1-Introduction to building regularisation



*Have you ever needed to regularise building works carried out without the proper authorisation?*



*Have you ever found yourself in a situation where work had already started without a prior application to the competent local authority?*



If your answer is yes, you will certainly have heard of [***building regularisation***](/en/blog/italian-building-regularization-2024). This is a fundamental mechanism for regularising building works. In this article, in particular, we will examine the SCIA (certified notification of commencement of activity) in sanatoria procedure, clearly outlining the steps required to apply for SCIA in sanatoria. We will also discover together how to make use of this legal opportunity to bring unauthorised building alterations into compliance, where possible.



## 2-Which works require a SCIA



The works requiring [***a certified notification of commencement of activity***](/en/blog/italian-scia-building-notification-guide) include the following: [*(Art.22 of the Italian Presidential Decree 380/01)*](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#022)



**1-EXTRAORDINARY MAINTENANCE**, where they concern the structural parts of the building or its façades. **Extraordinary maintenance** means all works and alterations needed to renew and replace parts, including structural parts, of buildings, as well as to install and integrate sanitary and technological services, provided that they do not alter the buildings’ overall volume and do not involve urbanistically significant changes to intended uses that increase the urban load.



**2-BUILDING RENOVATION WORKS**, excluding those that “result in a building organism that is wholly or partly different from the previous one, where they also involve changes to the buildings’ overall volume or, solely for properties located in homogeneous zone A, changes to the intended use, as well as works involving alterations to the shape or overall volume of buildings or to the façades of properties protected under the [Code of Cultural Heritage and Landscape referred to in Legislative Decree 22 January 2004, no. 42](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2004_0042.htm), and, furthermore, works



involving building renovation that entail the demolition and reconstruction of buildings located in areas protected under [Article 136, paragraph 1, letters c) and d)](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2004_0042.htm#136), and [142 of the code referred to in Legislative Decree 22 January 2004, no. 42](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2004_0042.htm#142), or the restoration of collapsed or demolished buildings located in the same areas, in both cases where changes to the shape, façades, footprint or planimetric-volume and typological characteristics of the existing building are planned, or where increases in volume are planned”



## 3-What SCIA in sanatoria is and when it is required

What SCIA in sanatoria is and when it is required

SCIA in sanatoria, like a building permit in sanatoria, is a conformity assessment, referred to in [*Art.37 of the Italian Presidential Decree 380/01*](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#037) as follows:



***Art. 37 (L) - Works carried out without or in breach of the certified notification of commencement of activity and conformity assessment***



1. Carrying out building works referred to in [Article 22](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#022), paragraphs 1 and 2, without or in breach of the certified notification of commencement of activity entails a financial penalty equal to twice the increase in the property’s market value resulting from the works, and in any event not less than 516 euros.



2. Where works carried out without a certified notification of commencement of activity consist of restoration and conservation works referred to in letter c) of Article 3, carried out on properties subject to restrictions under national and regional laws, as well as under other urban-planning rules in force, the authority responsible for supervising compliance with the restriction may, without prejudice to the application of other measures and sanctions provided for by current rules, order restoration at the responsible party’s expense and impose a financial penalty of between 516 and 10.329 euros.



3. Where the works referred to in paragraph 2 are carried out on properties, including unrestricted properties, located in the areas indicated in letter A of [Article 2 of the Ministerial Decree of 2 April 1968](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/1968_1444.htm#02), the head or manager of the office requests a specific binding opinion from the Ministry of Cultural Heritage and Activities concerning restoration or the imposition of the financial penalty referred to in paragraph 1. If the opinion is not issued within sixty days of the request, the head or manager of the office acts independently. In such cases, the financial penalty of between 516 and 10.329 euros referred to in paragraph 2 does not apply.



4. Where the completed works comply with the urban-planning and building rules in force both when the works were carried out and when the application was submitted, the person responsible for the abuse or the property owner may obtain regularisation for the works by paying an amount, no more than 5.164 euros and no less than 516 euros, set by the person responsible for the procedure in relation to the increase in the property’s value assessed by the land agency.



5. Without prejudice to the provisions of [Article 23, paragraph 6](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#023), a certified notification of commencement of activity submitted voluntarily while the works are in progress entails payment, by way of a sanction, of 516 euros.



6. Failure to submit the certified notification of commencement of activity does not entail the application of the sanctions provided for in [Article 44](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#044). The application of the sanctions referred to in [Articles 31, 33, 34, 35](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#031) and [44](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#044) and of the conformity assessment referred to in Article 36 remains unaffected where the conditions relating to the works carried out are met.



We can therefore say that SCIA in sanatoria is a type of authorisation that makes it possible to regularise building abuses, namely works carried out without prior authorisation or the issue of a building title and therefore in breach of building regulations.



It is important not to confuse SCIA in sanatoria with a building amnesty, which is [*“a legislative measure issued by Parliament or the Government by way of derogation for a property-related building offence. Within a specified period, it allows an application to be made for an abuse in building matters to be accepted without incurring criminal consequences.”*](https://www.studiomagnano.it/pratiche-edilizie/condono-edilizio/)



## 4-How can SCIA in sanatoria help you?



This procedure is very important within the complex landscape of Italian construction because it makes it possible to “remedy”, and therefore regularise, a building situation, offering the opportunity to comply with the rules currently in force.



> I have often encountered situations, especially during the peak period of the Superbonus, that required a regularisation application to regularise discrepancies present inside a property.



For these reasons, based on my practical experience, I think it is useful to provide an explanatory example to clarify what we are discussing:



I have inherited a house and would like to make substantial alterations to the property without affecting its volumes or external façades. However, after consulting a professional technician, they discovered through access to records—which allows people to view or request copies of documents relating to building procedures—that the property did not correspond to the latest approved project drawings and titles submitted. We noticed that renovations and alterations had been carried out over the years which, unfortunately, had also involved structural parts of the property. This is where building regularisation comes into play, and more specifically SCIA in sanatoria, since these are renovations of a certain type.



Thanks to this type of application, however, I can regularise all works carried out in breach of the rules in the past and then proceed with the renovations I wanted to make to the inherited property.



Before celebrating, however, one condition must be met: the rules in force both at the time of the abuse and when the regularisation application is submitted must be complied with. We will look at what this specifically means later.



This article addresses precisely these needs, explaining what building regularisation means, when it is required, how it differs from a building permit in sanatoria and why it is useful to rely on a specialised technician when dealing with this type of application.



All the information provided will make it easier to understand the so-called conformity assessments and will answer the most common questions directly.



**That said, let us look in detail at the types of SCIA in sanatoria:**



**1- LATE SCIA:** as the name suggests, this applies when work is still under way and a SCIA form has not been submitted to the local authority where the property concerned is located.



**2-SCIA IN SANATORIA:** applicable where the work has already been carried out and completed without authorisation under any building title.



**Today we will focus on SCIA IN SANATORIA.**



As in the example given above, in this second case a fundamental prerequisite for applying for building regularisation is verification of ***double compliance***.



*What does this mean?* It means that works carried out without a previously issued building title, or without any authorisation or application, must, when checked by an appointed technician, comply with the rules in force both at the time of the abuse and when the application is submitted.



*For example,* if a building abuse was committed in 1986 in breach of the rules in force, this necessarily means that building regularisation cannot be pursued today. The opposite also applies: if works, renovation or extraordinary maintenance were carried out in 1986 in compliance with the rules applicable at the time but do not comply with the rules currently in force, building regularisation cannot be pursued.



> I can proceed with SCIA in sanatoria only if the works constituting the offence comply both with the rules in force at the time of the offence and with the rules in force when the application is submitted.



## 5-Who must submit SCIA in sanatoria?



> Having dealt with many building-regularisation procedures over the years, my advice is always to rely on an industry expert, such as a qualified technician.



If, following a detailed check, the property satisfies the double-compliance requirement, the application must be submitted to the competent local authority either by the property owner or by the appointed technician. The latter will complete all the documentation, prepare a technical report demonstrating double compliance, and attach technical drawings showing the property’s current condition, its last approved condition and, finally, a comparison demonstrating which discrepancies are to be regularised through the application.



The competent office and the municipal technician will then check the documentation submitted.



This documentation can be completed digitally through the local authorities’ own portals.



For obvious reasons, when we own properties that do not comply, what interests us most is *when do we actually have to pay to regularise the building abuses?*



- *N.B.: The information below refers only to the building-regularisation application and excludes the technician’s fee and other factors that determine the total cost.*



## 6-What sanctions must be paid for SCIA in sanatoria?

Sanctions to be paid for SCIA in sanatoria

**We distinguish between two cases concerning the payment of sanctions for SCIA in sanatoria:**



***1-In the first case*** we identify an application for SCIA in sanatoria where double compliance has been established, meaning compliance with the rules in force both at the time of the abuse and currently.



***2-In the second case*** we consider the sanctions payable where a SCIA is submitted while works are in progress, that is, when the work has already started without first submitting the appropriate application to the competent authority and obtaining approval. In this latter case, double compliance is not required because the aim is not to regularise a building offence committed in the past, but simply to authorise work that started voluntarily without the appropriate checks by the local authority.



**Let us examine both cases in detail (with reference to [the Italian Presidential Decree 380/01](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#020)):**



**1-SANCTION FOR SCIA IN SANATORIA WITH DOUBLE COMPLIANCE**



As cited in [*Art. 37-Works carried out without or in breach of the certified notification of commencement of activity and conformity assessment, paragraph 4:*](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#037)



*“Where the completed works comply with the urban-planning and building rules in force both when the works were carried out and when the application was submitted, the person responsible for the abuse or the property owner may obtain regularisation for the works by paying an amount of no more than 5.164 euros and no less than 516 euros, set by the person responsible for the procedure in relation to the increase in the property’s value assessed by the land agency.”*



**2-SANCTION FOR WORK STARTED WITHOUT SUBMITTING A SCIA TO THE LOCAL AUTHORITY**



As cited in [*Art. 37-Works carried out without or in breach of the certified notification of commencement of activity and conformity assessment, paragraph 5:*](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#037)



*“A certified notification of commencement of activity submitted voluntarily while the works are in progress entails payment, by way of a sanction, of 516 euros.”*



## 7-How long does it take for SCIA in sanatoria to be issued?



*“The head or manager of the competent municipal office shall issue a reasoned decision within sixty days, after which the application is deemed to have been refused.”*



This means that the competent authority will take 60 days to accept or reject the building-regularisation application. In this specific type of building regularisation, tacit consent does not apply; once the period of 60 days has elapsed, if no favourable decision has been received, the application must be deemed rejected.



## 8-Example SCIA in sanatoria form



Although all applications for building titles can now be managed directly through the relevant local authority’s portal, for a better understanding we provide below an example of a SCIA form that can be completed. It shows in detail what will be requested and which field to select when the application concerns SCIA in sanatoria.



Here is the specific section where you must identify the “classification of the works” and indicate that what you are requesting is an application for SCIA in sanatoria:

Example SCIA in sanatoria form

By ticking point “C.3, you indicate that what you are requesting through this form is a regularisation of works which, following the appropriate assessments and checks, comply with the urban-planning and building rules in force both when they were carried out and when the notification was submitted.



If you would like to see the complete certified notification of commencement of activity form, I have included the full form [here.](http://www.glossarioedilizia.it/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/SCIA-nazionale-editabile-2018.pdf)



## 9-Conclusions



SCIA in sanatoria is a fundamentally important legal instrument for property owners and construction professionals, providing a route to regularise building works carried out without the necessary authorisations. Understanding the procedures, benefits, responsibilities and sanctions presented in this article creates an opportunity to comply with the rules in force, avoid legal risks and enhance the value of property assets.



Submitting and obtaining approval for SCIA in sanatoria requires care and precision, highlighting the importance of relying on qualified professionals in construction and urban planning. Involving an experienced technician not only facilitates the completion and submission of the necessary documentation but also ensures an accurate assessment of double compliance, a crucial aspect of the success of the regularisation procedure.



In conclusion, SCIA in sanatoria represents an opportunity to regularise historic building situations, and understanding it is essential for anyone facing, deliberately or otherwise, building-abuse situations and wishing to avoid serious consequences for their property.



## Frequently asked questions:



## What is the difference between late CILA and SCIA in sanatoria?



Late CILA does not require double compliance. It is submitted to the competent authority when work has already started without prior notification.



## What is the difference between a building permit in sanatoria and SCIA in sanatoria?



The difference lies in the type of works. All works falling within the scope of a building permit, described in [*Art.10 of the Italian Presidential Decree 380 /01*](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#010), are subject to a building permit in sanatoria.



## What is the difference between a building amnesty and SCIA in sanatoria?



Both make it possible to regularise building abuses, but the fundamental difference is that an amnesty is a special law limited to a specific period, whereas building regularisation through sanatoria is an administrative measure provided for by current urban-planning rules [*(Italian Presidential Decree 380/01\_Art.37)*](https://www.bosettiegatti.eu/info/norme/statali/2001_0380.htm#037)



## If a building irregularity did not comply with the rules in force at the time of the abuse, can I still regularise works carried out in the past?



No. If double compliance does not exist—that is, compliance with the rules in force at the time of the abuse and on the date the regularisation application is submitted—the building abuse cannot be regularised.
