Labour Shortage in Spain’s Construction Sector

News reports, surveys and statistical data point to a growing labour shortage in the construction sector. From more than 2,5 million in 2008 to fewer than 1,5 in 2024. Understanding the context, where the shortage is mainly occurring and the principal contributing causes is the first step towards recognising a reality that will have to be addressed sooner or later. Although many contributing factors are beyond the control of the self-employed, SMEs and micro-SMEs because they form part of macroeconomic realities or international geopolitical tensions, or require intervention by public or supranational bodies, there are several ways to mitigate them and lay the foundations for recovering and retaining both skilled and unskilled labour, making the sector more attractive to young people, who are under-represented in Spain’s construction market in 2024.

According to the INE, the highest number of unfilled vacancies in Spain since 2016 is in the construction sector

Contents

1. Introduction

Labour shortages in the construction sector have, among others, the following consequences:

a) Higher wages for available workers, which in turn leads to increased costs for businesses.

b) Delays in deliveries and in meeting the deadlines for work certification, affecting customer satisfaction and the reputation of those carrying out the work.

c) Loss of competitiveness, reflected, among other things, in the greater movement of skilled staff between different projects because of the difficulty of finding tradespeople with the optimum knowledge, skills and experience.

If the above is combined with the rise in construction-material prices observed from 2020, which continues to date because of persistent geopolitical and supply tensions (although these are showing signs of improvement), the situation becomes even more difficult.

Although it is common to the economy and society in general, an ageing workforce is particularly pronounced in our sector. The average age has been rising and, according to data from the National Statistics Institute, stands at 45 years for more than 50% of workers, nearly 8 years higher than the average in 2007 before the property crisis.

2. From bad beginnings come bad results. Current state of Spain’s labour market in 2024. What about the EU?

The devastation caused to Spain’s construction sector by the property crisis, or housing-market crisis, is still being felt. To illustrate this, let us consider some data on the development of Spain’s construction-sector labour market between 2007 (the year before the outbreak of the US subprime mortgage crisis in 2008, which caused the widely known economic, social and institutional crisis in Spain) and 2022.

Ageing in the main occupations.

- Bricklayers or masons: average age 2007: 39,9. In 2022: 48,1. (Difference: 8,2 years)

- Electricians: average age 2007: 35,5. In 2022: 42,3. (Difference: 6,8 years)

- Plumbers: 2007: average age 2007: 34,1. In 2022: 43,8. (Difference: 9,7 years)

- Painters: 2007: average age 2007: 37,1. In 2022: 44,2. (Difference: 7,1 years)

- Labourers: 2007: average age 2007: 33. In 2022: 39,1. (Difference: 6,1 years)

- Construction sector: average age 2007: 37,3. In 2022: 45,1. (Difference: 6,1 years)

"More than 55% of workers employed in Spain’s construction sector in 2022 were over 45 years old." (INE)

3. What can self-employed workers, SMEs and micro-SMEs do about the labour shortage?

It is a difficult question. We will try to answer it from the perspective of self-employed workers, SMEs and micro-SMEs. This is a complex problem requiring the participation of several economic and social agents beyond the control of small businesses, which could nevertheless:

a) Retain the workforce already in place:

- Improve pay and create safer working environments.

- Improve staff’s ongoing training by making use of courses offered by national public authorities and the NextGenerationEU funds, while investing directly in this essential area.

- Increase job satisfaction by implementing recognition and benefits programmes.

b) Attract new talent: Traditionally, construction has been regarded as a rough, demanding sector involving exhausting work:

- Digitalisation: it should be borne in mind that the young people who need to join the construction sector belong to what has become known as the “digital native generation”. The use of apps or applications for construction management that are flexible, modern and able to facilitate tracking the costs associated with hours worked, often on different projects throughout the day or week, can make it easier for young people to join a sector such as construction, which lags behind technologically on site.

Using these applications also enables us to work more efficiently because they reduce costs by facilitating tasks that historically required more labour, significantly reducing errors and the resulting need to redo work, and enabling real-time tracking of costs and project progress. This also helps with making early decisions based on real and reliable data.

If, for example, the need for certain tradespeople or specialised workers to move between different projects is a consequence of staff shortages, this type of application could:

- improve communication between projects and the office, where decisions are generally made.

- provide more reliable tracking and allocation of costs to different projects.

- plan the travel of the staff concerned more safely and efficiently by providing real-time information on the progress of different project milestones.

- optimise deliveries and materials management on projects according to the staff available.

- make the allocation of specific tasks to workers more flexible remotely.

- avoid unnecessary travel to projects because issues or unforeseen events can be documented on site with photos, text messages and voice messages.

- reduce the time spent managing costs because these applications include technology such as Artificial Intelligence (AI), which instantly converts delivery notes and invoices into accounting records (Excel), tracks hours worked and clock-ins, records material costs, and more.

- organise all documentation (setting-out records, completion certificates, inspection records, reports, daily logs, etc.) in the cloud, enabling it to be located quickly and easily and allowing the electronic and remote signing of documents requiring it by all the agents involved.

4. Conclusions

. Statistical data point to a growing labour shortage in the construction sector, an ageing workforce and a lack of generational replacement, particularly in specialised activities. A similar situation is described across the EU.

. Retaining existing talent through employment incentives and improved remuneration is therefore necessary.

. Invest in improving the training of existing employees or self-employed workers, making use, among other resources, of the NextGenerationEU funds, which even provide for online training where applicable.

. On the other hand, today it is almost essential for self-employed workers and SMEs to adopt a digitalisation approach for their processes, seeking efficiency and cost reduction while also making the sector attractive to the young talent it needs, which at this point is mainly digitally native. The NextGenerationEU funds that you can apply for through the digital agents of the so-called Kit Digital provide for non-repayable grants covering, for example, mobile-app licences and the purchase of the necessary IT equipment.

Try Mela for freeRequest a demo

Download Mela

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Written byLeo Góngora