Site accounting: a formula to help you make a profit

How much is a construction site worth? Let’s start with a formula that brings together all its variables—the contract value, the resources used, the time involved and any problems that may need addressing—to get to the heart of the matter. The ultimate aim: to turn a site that is perpetually behind schedule (a delay means an additional cost of even 10, 20, 30%!) into a project that meets its deadlines or is even completed early. Because for you, this means turning systematic losses into reliable profits!

Site accounting

Site accounting: how much is a construction site worth?

Today we’re simplifying a complex problem: how much is a construction site worth? To do this, we’ll adopt an engineering rather than a mathematical approach—in other words, we’ll make broad approximations to get to the heart of the matter in just a few steps. But before simplifying, let’s start with the hypotheses, our assumptions.

Hypothesis 1

It is 2022 and the construction market in Italy is growing. In this situation, companies have to turn down some jobs and therefore lose potential profits.

Hypothesis 2

We will not consider depreciation or other slightly more complex accounting operations—in short, we’ll simplify. Having made these 2 assumptions, we are ready to engineer (arm outstretched and hand waving) the value of our construction site.

Let’s start with a formula:

E = C - R - T - P where...

E = the value of the construction site, meaning how many euros we gain or lose from a site

C = the Contract value, meaning how much money the client has committed to spending

R = the Resources used to carry out the work

T = Time, including delays

P = Problems

Site accounting: analysing the components of this equation

E: the value of the construction site

These are the euros left in the company account at the end of the operation. Will the figure be positive or negative?

C: the contract value

This is the value of the estimate accepted by the client. It is the only definitely positive value in the equation. Entire books have been written about this value, and it is not the subject of this article. We would, however, like to make 2 observations:

  • Restaurants are becoming increasingly expensive, yet we cannot wait to eat out and try Michelin-starred menus. Why? Because chefs and the entire agri-food supply chain have invested heavily in traceability, transparency, quality and innovation. They have reinvented themselves. They have built a professional image that can be presented to the public. When we go to a restaurant, we increasingly feel part of a story. They have learnt how to make us dream. Will we be able to make the same leap in construction? Then our C may rise. By how much? It depends on how many Michelin stars we bring home.
  • The superbonus is radically changing how C is calculated. Normally, you decide which works you want to carry out and then determine the cost; after a couple of iterations, you arrive at the final figure. Today, people calculate how much a property can be financed through the superbonus and assume that this is C. Wrong! We must always start with the menu and then determine the cost of the meal, never start with the client’s wallet. This is also because the works carried out under the superbonus determine the property’s final value. Explaining this point correctly to our clients, with passion and respect for the money they are investing, will allow us to build our Michelin stars. Be careful: the unified price list is only a control tool, so let’s not use it as a justification.

R: the resources used

Resources are needed to carry out the work: staff, materials, services, hire costs, machinery and so on...

The resources used have a cost, so R represents the site costs. R is the only definitely negative value in the equation, so the aim is always to reduce the resources used to carry out the work. However, let’s remember what we said earlier about restaurants: we need to be able to create a valuable experience for the client, and this will allow us to increase C.

Ultimately, the real value we are interested in is “C - R”, not R independently of C.

An extremely important point to consider concerns the speed at which R is monitored. Cost control acts as the site’s regulation cycle, with a fundamental impact on activities and relationships with the client.

How long does it take us to know the site costs?

On average, we have a delay of around 3 weeks, meaning that today we know how much the site cost up to 3 weeks ago

If it cost too much, we take corrective action 3 weeks late. In 3 weeks, we have already moved on to a subsequent phase of the work, so we will correct on the roof the cost problems generated while building the foundations.

Explaining this concept to our clients is almost impossible: it would be like being served the main course without salt at a restaurant because they realised they had over-salted the starters. How can we correct this problem?

The digitalisation of site reports (including the automatic reading of delivery notes and invoices) can help us drastically reduce the delay in cost control. Some mobile applications can collect data quickly directly on site and present it instantly to the accountant and business owner.

As far as digitalisation strategies are concerned, the key is simplicity when collecting data. Once the data has been collected, even our Excel spreadsheets will be very quick at performing the most complex calculations. The problem is always how long it takes for site data to reach the Excel spreadsheet.

Our recommendation is to choose a simple mobile app rather than a complex business management system for collecting information from the site

Apps are used to collect data quickly on site; business management systems serve other purposes.

T: time

This is the real star of the equation: the most underestimated factor, and the one with an unexpected impact. Let’s start with a statistic: all small and medium-sized construction business owners talk about sites that are perpetually behind schedule.

“The site was supposed to take 10 months, but it took 12 months. Never mind, that’s how it is.” This seemingly simplistic phrase actually hides a net loss of 20% of the site’s total value!

Let’s see why: first of all, let’s remember that we assumed that in 2021 and 2022 our companies received more requests for work than they could manage, thanks to the boost provided by the superbonus 110%. We would respond by implementing 2 strategies: growing or becoming more efficient. The former would need to be managed during the years when demand falls; the latter would become a competitive weapon, an improvement we would retain permanently.

Let’s return to time and the value of the site. Let’s assume that our site, with an expected duration of 10 months, has a value of 100.000 euros, and that immediately afterwards—as soon as the first site was completed—we could have started similar work.

A delay of 2 months creates a cost of 20.000 euros!

In economics, this is called opportunity cost. In manufacturing, it is called lost production, and it is one of the parameters discussed continuously within factories.

How sensitive is construction to this cost? Does saying that the site took 2 months longer trigger the same alarm in us as saying that it cost 20% more? Is it possible to solve this problem in construction?

An interesting answer comes from the annual monitoring of the construction sector conducted by KPMG in 2019, “Future-Ready Index. Leaders and followers in the engineering & construction industry”.

KPMG interviewed 223 people from 144 leading companies worldwide in construction and engineering. It classified the companies according to an index designed to measure how prepared companies are for future challenges (Future-Ready Index). The graph below shows the result of this classification.

When building the index, great importance was given to the digitalisation strategy, measured for each company by both its inclination towards, and adoption of, the most innovative technologies. The top 20, the index champions (the innovative leaders), consistently demonstrate two things:

  1. The leadership of the top companies shows strong management commitment to innovation and takes an active part in guiding change, demonstrating that innovation does not happen by chance
  2. The top companies invest heavily in technology, especially in:
    1. Mobile solutions for collecting data directly on site and cloud platforms for analysing data (Data and Analytics),
    2. BIM in design
    3. Integrated project management with mobile site platforms (Integrated project management)

And what results do the top companies achieve? As the graph below shows, they complete 60% of their projects ahead of schedule, with delivery times brought forward by 10%. That’s right! In 60% of cases, they complete the site used as our earlier example in 9 months, gaining an additional 10.000 euros in available time. In our equation, their T is not a negative term but a positive one!

What do the others do? The percentage falls to 14%, eventually reaching—and we are talking about leading construction and engineering companies worldwide—companies that cannot complete any project ahead of schedule. Even among the largest companies, those lagging furthest behind in site digitalisation are forced to accept T as a cost rather than a gain.

P: Problems

We come to P, the final parameter in the equation. Hidden within this parameter are 2 main factors: variations and current and future disputes. Clearly, this parameter can be either positive or negative, and is often slightly negative.

The typical case is when a site has a few variations from the design—not too significant—and we decide to absorb these costs to avoid arguments with the client and works management. In rarer cases, this parameter can also be very negative and reduce the value of a site to zero. This happens when a financial dispute arises with works management and the client, not to mention the resulting reputational damage.

If you often find yourself in this situation, you need to do something to change it and will probably need to invest heavily in improving the quality or traceability of your sites

Where should you start?

First, you will need to track everything that happens on site and then analyse it critically and with an open mind. To track things efficiently, we recommend starting with site photo management and the digitalisation of the site diary.

If you adopt this process, you will be able to correct any execution errors and demonstrate the cost of variations requested by the client and works management. In our equation, the result is to turn P from a negative term into a slightly positive one.

So, if you keep all these factors under control, you can mitigate the risk of failure, continuously monitor costs and timings and, ultimately, increase the value of your construction site.

By answering these 3 questions you can receive a personalised report about your company to find out how much you could actually save by using Mela.

Try Mela for freeRequest a demo

Download Mela

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Written byEmanuele Zamponi