Safety Coordinator and Covid: the cost-estimation model with itemised entries
Discover how to estimate Covid safety costs on construction sites, with the cost items, responsibilities and model for Safety Coordinators.
Safety Coordinator and Covid. “Are Covid costs specific safety costs or not? Who must bear these costs? Which cost items should be included?” These are some of the questions that have involved Safety Coordinators since the beginning of the pandemic. Let us now clarify the matter and, with the help of Dr Adriano Ciani, provide a useful model for the Safety Coordinator to estimate all anti-Covid cost items fairly and with due consideration.
Safety Coordinator and Covid
Safety Coordinator and Covid: who must bear the costs? And how should these new costs be managed on the construction site?
To orient ourselves, let us start with the legislation: in Italy's Consolidated Safety Act – Legislative Decree 81/08 and subsequent amendments, and in particular in Annex XV, point 2 and point 4, pandemic risk is not provided for. Since there was therefore no national pandemic plan, D.Lgs.81/08 was also deficient in this respect.
Consequently, faced with an exceptional and unexpected situation, the Government prudently suspended a large part of work activities while awaiting a solution. As a result, in contracts, the Contracting Authorities, through their Works Director, had to suspend the works due to force majeure.
Once a solution had been found at the beginning of May 2020, construction sites restarted, but the provisions established in the various DPCMs on Covid-19, issued to date, generate new costs on construction sites that the Appointed Contractor must and will have to bear in order to ensure the health and safety of its workers in the workplace.
These new costs must be estimated in the PSC (Safety and Coordination Plan) and therefore paid to the Appointed Contractor. The latter will then, pursuant to Art.26 of Legislative Decree 81/08, allocate them proportionally to all Executing Contractors, whether subcontractors or otherwise, operating on the site.
Anti-Covid-19 safety: these new costs are borne by the Contracting Authority
Safety Coordinator and Covid: a law to clarify matters
The first measure to clarify matters was the DPCM of 24 April 2020, subsequently converted into law (24 April 2020, no. 27), which essentially establishes that the costs incurred for anti-infection measures against Covid-19 must be paid to the Appointed Contractor. Annex 7 to the DPCM also contains an indication of the mandatory safety requirements to be guaranteed on the construction site.
The provisions for construction sites set out in Annex 7 enable the Safety Coordinator to create a model for estimating the costs arising from the ongoing pandemic emergency
Are you a CSE? Here is the model with the expenditure items prepared by Dr Ciani
However, please note that both the CSP (during the design stage) and the CSE (during the execution stage) must consider many variables: for example, the number of workers on site, which may change from day to day depending on the activities to be carried out and the relevant skills (carpenter, electrician, plumber, etc.), as well as the duration of the works, the impact of work suspensions and the size of the construction site, etc.
Therefore, while the CSP, during the design stage, will provisionally quantify these new costs in its PSC on the basis of the average man-days expected on the construction site, derived from the total labour cost planned for carrying out the contract for the entire duration of the works, the CSE, during the execution stage, must refer to the “Works Diary” drawn up by the Works Director.
Furthermore, in connection with the S.A.L, the CSE must authorise payment of the Covid-19 costs actually incurred by the Appointed Contractor, based on the final accounts and therefore measured according to the quantities. Clearly, where penalties are applied to the Appointed Contractor for late completion of the works, the Covid-19 costs relating to that period will be borne entirely by the Contractor itself.
Failure to do all this could cause harm to the Contracting Authority (financial damage in the case of public works), namely facilitate the Appointed Contractor’s unlawful enrichment
To quantify the new costs at final accounting stage, the CSE must therefore rely on the Works Diary completed by the Works Director and on their own observations made during an inspection/site visit
Safety Coordinator and Covid: cost items and quantities
Now, what are the items contributing to these new Safety costs and, above all, what quantities are involved: safety masks, and how many? Sanitising products, and how many dispensers? But what needs to be sanitised? How often? What evidence is there that everything has been done correctly?
This is why the CSP needs to create a preliminary schedule that follows the DPCM directives and the Ministry guidelines, namely the ten-point checklist with a mathematical model that will then be used by the CSE to determine the corresponding final cost
Safety Coordinator and Covid. In summary, to guarantee suitable anti-infection safety measures on the construction site, the following are required:
Disposable face masks
Disposable latex gloves
Sanitising gel in dispensers
Protective workwear
Safety glasses or a protective shield: where work is carried out in environments affected by droplets, a sanitised visor will be required
Cleaning, sanitisation and suitable ventilation of communal areas—but which ones? Certainly areas such as offices, toilets and bathrooms, but also places and vehicles where people are together, such as the minibus used by workers every day
Sanitisation of commonly used equipment
Staff training on the subject
Staggering of work: shifts are arranged so that there is as little interpersonal contact as possible
Specialist signage to be used on construction sites
Updating the POS
A procedure for measuring the body temperature of workers assigned to the construction site or authorised third parties when they enter the site.
Other measures provided for specific situations
This means at least 13/15 cost items!
To do everything in compliance with the rules, it is necessary to follow the DPCMs and also pay attention to the Orders issued from time to time by the relevant Region.
Clearly, if a Covid infection case were to occur on the construction site, using the method would protect the CSP/CSE and therefore the Works Supervisor (RL), reducing, if not eliminating, the substance of the accusation
Download the model with the expenditure items prepared by Dr Ciani
The Ciani method may therefore prove useful to the CSP/CSE, the RL of a Public Administration or a private Contracting Authority, and also to the Appointed Contractor. It also produces a fair quantification of safety costs arising from the Covid-19 pandemic emergency and, in the event of a dispute between the parties, helps achieve a fair amicable resolution
One final clarification: holding a Green Pass (from 06/08/2021) does not cancel the adoption on the construction site of the aforementioned MPPs (Preventive and Protective Safety Measures), nor the related costs.