Safety Coordinator requirements: minutes templates using the Ciani method

The work of the Safety Coordinator using the Ciani method. An effective system for managing the complexity associated with three fundamental pillars of a construction site: safety, time and costs.

Safety Coordinator requirements

Listen to our podcast "La chiacchiera dell'Umarell"!

Listen to "Knowledge, method, process - the ABC of a good construction-site Safety Coordinator" on Spreaker.

Safety Coordinator requirements. When we talk about managing complexity, we think that the work of the Safety Coordinator during the Execution phase (CSE) can be an excellent example, caught as it is between accident risks, and the time and costs of the construction site.

Successfully navigating this path requires knowledge, passion and process. The final aspect, process, is no less important: approaching this profession without a process creates scope for problems (often criminal ones!) and inefficiencies.

We also know that the CSE itself represents a cost for the construction site, which is why the available budget is limited. As also provided for by the legislation, a CSE is not continuously present on site (high-level supervision) and usually manages several sites at the same time. So how can we maximise the impact on site safety, making this impact an investment for both the client and the companies carrying out the work?

Safety Coordinator requirements: a method for establishing the correct process

From 1999 to 2021, Dr Ciani developed a method consisting of an integrated phase-based structured process, to carry out effectively both the activities of the CSP – Safety Coordinator during Design – and those of the CSE – Safety Coordinator during Execution.

Today we will look at the method section concerning the CSE, clearly represented by the attached flow diagram – DdF, which you can download here.

The methodology, validated by two certification bodies (DNV and RINA), was tested in the field with positive results on 80 Public Construction Sites. This methodology therefore constitutes a quality procedure, namely a Technical Contribution for carrying out CSE activities in compliance with Art. 92 of the Italian Legislative Decree 81/08 (D.Lgs.) as amended.

The complete methodology consists of 21 validated templates or technical tools, useful for managing the process appropriately within optimised timeframes, and includes both management of the design phase and management during the construction works.

Let us now give a brief description and see how it can be implemented, focusing on the construction phases where costs and risks rise.

Mela, given Dr Ciani’s availability, wanted to make the Ciani method easy to use in its app by adding and making available to all users the templates considered most strategic (in the Flow Diagram, they are highlighted in blue):

For the preliminary phase, that is, before work begins:

MOD 05 – Identification of site roles for safety coordination

RC – Coordination meeting invitation

MOD 00a – Preliminary-phase check

MOD 03a – Preliminary coordination meeting

For the execution phase, that is, once work has begun:

MOD 08a – Site visit minutes / report (during execution, once work has begun)

MOD 08b – Anomaly identified during a site visit and requirements

MOD 10 – Suitability verification with resolution of identified non-conformities

MOD 20a – Minutes confirming completion of work-control activities

MOD 20b – Certificate of completion of site dismantling (site clearance)

Download the Excel template for the simplified Ciani method here

CSE minutes templates made available on Mela

The templates are available to new platform registrants or can be requested by writing to contact@mela.work.

Safety Coordinator requirements: the 3 main phases

Let us compare implementation of the model with traditional tools and with dedicated mobile and cloud tools.

In both cases, the CSE’s activity can be greatly simplified by dividing it into 3 main phases:

  1. Preliminary Phase – we have received the appointment as CSE and must ensure that the site is properly prepared and verify the suitability of the site’s safety documentation.

  2. Execution Phase – carry out checks during the works.

  3. Closing the site, ending the CSE’s control activities.

Preliminary Phase: properly prepare the site and verify the suitability of the site’s Safety documentation

Ready to start? Not yet. The CSE carries out a check and, following the checklist in Template 00a, then convenes the preliminary coordination meeting (the first coordination meeting), drawing up Template 03a at the end.

In fact, in the first phase we must make sure that all the site stakeholders – the client/RL, the appointed contractor, subcontractors and other contractors, and self-employed workers – have completed both their homework (paperwork) and their classwork.

The crucial checkpoint in this phase is the preliminary coordination meeting, where we will ensure that:

  1. The Safety and Coordination Plan (PSC) has been properly presented and all participants have understood it

  2. The risks associated with

    1. preparatory interventions to make the site area safe before the start of the contracted works – see, for example, the VOB – or other actions needed to set up the site

    2. the first phase of the contracted works (start-up), as well as the main risks during the works, have been presented

    3. activities involving interference risks and activities potentially interfering with our site (adjacent workplaces and/or concurrent construction sites)

  3. The Safety Programme has been examined

  4. The Site Safety Layout has been examined

  5. Adequate time has been allowed to listen to and assess the appointed contractor’s proposals for improving site safety

  6. The functional organisation chart for managing site safety has been defined

  7. All elements have been defined so that the Works Supervisor or client can prepare and send the appropriate preliminary notification to the relevant authorities, which the appointed contractor must display on site together with the Site Noticeboard

  8. A site has been set up on site to store all safety-related documentation for rapid consultation, including by the authorities responsible for inspections

Only following that preliminary meeting and the complete acceptance of the PSC, will the appointed contractor prepare its own Operational Safety Plan – POS compliant with Annex XV point 3.2 and the related Safety documentation, which it will send to the CSE.

Only after the checks referred to in Art. 92 of the Italian Legislative Decree 81/08 (D.Lgs.) have produced a positive result, the CSE has given written authorisation and the Works Director has completed the relevant formalities, may work begin on site

Beware of POS documents made by photocopying or left incomplete: they represent a risk to everyone, as well as creating the possibility of penalties or measures suspending the appointed contractor’s business activity and therefore all its sites, not just ours.

Execution Phase: carrying out checks during the works

At this point the works are fully under way and the focus must be the safety of the people working on site and of those who come into contact with the site (for example… let’s not drop the crane onto the neighbour’s house!).

Here, the CSE activity with the highest added value is certainly the site visit, and Template 08a helps us avoid forgetting any essential stage of the visit.

But what do you do when anomalies are identified? Our question concerns documentation, not practical action. Whenever an anomaly is confirmed on site, every CSE promptly issues written instructions for resolving it, including by suspending individual work activities and, in the most serious cases, proposing to the RL or client that the works be suspended, or that non-compliant companies or self-employed workers be removed from the site.

Here we want to describe how the CSE can:

1 – Track the results of their inspection visit, whether positive or negative

2 – Ensure that all arrangements are first received clearly and then resolved according to best practice, the applicable legislation and within reasonable timeframes

Indeed, we should bear in mind that the CSE is unlikely to be back at the same site the following day, so they must devise a mechanism for managing the problem remotely.

The analogue CSE

To be clear: the analogue CSE is not the paper-based CSE. They have gone to the site with a mobile phone and taken photographs of the problems identified, issued written instructions to the site manager or site director to resolve the anomalies identified during the inspection, and then ensured that everything was properly resolved.

They now have to return to the office, scan the paper template 08 into PDF format, download the photographs and archive them correctly, then send the signed minutes from the site to the appointed contractor and, for information, to the RL or client and the DL. How? By certified email, of course, then printing and filing the receipts! Perhaps the site manager or site director does not have certified email, but someone in the office will read it.

With Mela, the CSE can be sure (and can demonstrate) that they have tracked their activity and sent the results to the recipients.

Finished? Yes, if there were no open points, situations still to be resolved, restricted areas, suspended work activities or protective measures to be added ….?

In the latter case, using template 10, they can wait remotely for a prompt response from the appointed contractor, formally confirming that the observations recorded in template 08 have been properly addressed and that all non-conformities identified during the site inspection have therefore been resolved, without necessarily having to return to that site the following day. A significant saving in time and costs.

In short, the analogue CSE always returns home with plenty of work to do and uses certified email to track communications, but with the app the saving is clear.

The digital CSE: the potential of the mobile tool

The digital CSE is still a bet, a frontier story that we are beginning to test and assess today, but one in which we have invested time and thought and in which we strongly believe.

The digital CSE is someone who makes full use of the potential of the digital tool they always carry in their pocket: the smartphone. They have also involved the appointed contractor carrying out the work in their enthusiasm.

They use Mela, or another mobile app with similar capabilities.

With Mela, the CSE can:

  • Simply collect data on site (photos, videos, voice notes and anything else)

  • Share data with the appointed contractor, who can view it, comment on it and become an active part of the improvement process

  • Complete minutes in the field (template 08a for the visit, template 08b for identified anomalies and template 10 for closing them, where necessary remotely.

  • Sign minutes directly on the mobile phone and collect the appointed contractor’s representatives’ signatures directly in the digital platform, both in person and remotely

  • Always have – thanks to the timestamp – a reliable date for the minutes and all information.

Now let us retrace the site visit: the CSE takes photographs, completes the minutes and collects signatures. They are informed about the resolution of problems directly on the platform, through immediate information from the site manager or site director of the appointed contractor. They can request details and mark the identified anomalies as resolved, including remotely.

Digital tools such as Mela therefore make it possible to reduce the work of “editing” (borrowing a term from cinema) and distributing information as much as possible.

Hours spent on minutes and certified email saved!

What is more, the quality of the work improves because the CSE properly informs the appointed contractor’s legal representative, while simultaneously checking the practical resolution of the problem with the people on site, thereby certifying that the activity has been properly completed to the RL or client.

Dismantling/site-clearance phase: closing the site and ending the CSE’s control activities

The works are finished and it is time to close the site. It is important for the CSE to distinguish between the end of the works and the complete dismantling/site clearance of the site, which corresponds to the actual end of the CSE’s control activities and therefore of their related responsibilities. Two templates, 20a and 20b, help us with precisely this.

The 9 templates, available to all subscribers to the Mela app, enable management of 90% of a CSE’s situations and obligations.

Contact us if you would like more information or clarification about any of the templates, or if you would like to implement others.

Try Mela for freeRequest a demo

Download Mela

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Written byAlessandro Cognigni