Building amnesty 2024: regulations, procedures, penalties and examples
Understand Italy’s building amnesty rules, procedures, penalties and practical examples, including double compliance, tolerances and graphic errors.
Italy’s regulatory framework for construction is extremely complex, and building amnesty forms part of it. The latter is essential when building offences are present, ranging from minor breaches to criminally relevant offences, in order to bring works and buildings back within the law. In this article, with reference to DPR 380/01, we explain in detail what is meant by building amnesty, when it is not necessary and when it must be submitted in the event of an offence. Through practical examples and references to legislation, we will guide you step by step through the building amnesty process, making it easier to understand and apply in accordance with the legislation in force.
Everything you need to know about building amnesty
Contents:
1.INTRODUCTION TO BUILDING AMNESTY:
Before going further into the article, I would like to open a brief parenthesis to explain why it is useful to know what building amnesty is in 2024 and, above all, when it is necessary, particularly during property sales.
Why is it useful to know what building amnesty is and when it is necessary?
When involved in a property sale, we may unfortunately encounter building offences that, until recently, neither the current owner nor the buyer knew existed.
My advice is always to check a property’s history when making an investment, to avoid finding yourself paying penalty after penalty to regularise all the discrepancies present—assuming they can actually be regularised—and hoping not to encounter situations where this is impossible, as happened to two of my clients last year.
Here is a brief summary, without going into excessive technical detail, of what happened:
"Not long ago, I surveyed a recently purchased property where the new owners simply wanted to make minor internal changes, such as replacing the flooring and demolishing and rebuilding some partition walls. The property seemed strange to both me and my surveyor colleague because the toilet room—the only toilet in the small flat—was detached from the rest of the home and could only be reached via the balcony, which was completely enclosed at the time of the survey (see the image below). We immediately suspected that this might be an irregularity. The conclusion? The new owners’ dream became a nightmare because, unfortunately, this discrepancy complied neither with the legislation in force nor with the legislation applicable when the offence occurred. As the property was in a landscape-protected area, the work could not be regularised and, consequently, reaching the toilet required leaving the home and crossing the terrace. This also led to structural alterations to the flat to create an internal WC. In the end, the owners had to pay far more than they had originally expected, not to mention all the related legal proceedings."
This is why I always recommend relying on a specialised professional, particularly during property sales, so that irregularities or offences can be identified immediately and difficult situations avoided.
Having closed this parenthesis about a personal experience, we can continue by examining the subject of this article in detail: building amnesty!
What is building amnesty and when is it necessary
Introduction: the crucial role of building amnesty
Building amnesty is a fundamental element in the context of town planning and property management in Italy. This process is not merely an administrative formality, but a bridge connecting a property’s past with present-day requirements and regulations, ensuring that building works comply with the law.
Over the years, building regulations have undergone numerous changes in response to safety, urban aesthetics and environmental sustainability needs. Consequently, many buildings constructed in earlier periods, whether intentionally or otherwise, are not compliant with current legislation. Building amnesty therefore emerges as an essential tool for resolving these discrepancies, allowing properties to comply with current rules without demolition or major renovation works.
The amnesty procedure is particularly relevant in a country with such a historic and complex building heritage as Italy, where the urban fabric has developed through layers accumulated over centuries. Through amnesty, it is possible to regularise various building situations, from minor internal changes to more significant works such as extensions or changes of use, ensuring that every alteration complies with legality, safety and integration within the urban context.
Building amnesty must not be confused with condono edilizio, an extraordinary measure used on several occasions in the past to address widespread unauthorised building. Unlike condono, building amnesty forms part of a standard regulatory framework, with standardised procedures and specific conditions for regularising works, established by the DPR 380/01.
Addressing building amnesty requires an in-depth understanding of local and national regulations, as well as a precise analysis of the property’s actual condition. It is a process involving various parties, from owners and architects to engineers and municipal technicians, each of whom plays a decisive role in ensuring successful regularisation.
In this article, we will explore this process in detail, examining its implications, the procedures to follow, practical examples and the most effective strategies for navigating the complex landscape of building amnesty, with the aim of offering a clear and detailed guide to anyone facing this need.
What options are available for regularising building works?
Under DPR 380/01, the Italian testo unico dell'edilizia (Consolidated Building Act), a property owner can pursue several procedures to regularise works that do not comply with current legislation.
Building permit in amnesty (Article 36)
Certified notice of commencement of works (SCIA) in amnesty (Article 37)
Late CILA (Certified Notice of Commencement of Works) (Article 6-bis)
These are the available routes, depending on the nature and seriousness of the building irregularities.
Today, however, we will focus particularly on SCIA in amnesty and the building permit in amnesty (declaration of compliance), since these procedures require double compliance and fully fall within the building amnesty process. As for late CILA, this is an administrative procedure consisting, as its name suggests, of submitting an ordinary CILA after works have already been carried out without an application having been submitted to the competent authority. It is also often called CILA in amnesty, but it is simply a CILA application submitted after the works have been completed. These works are normally non-structural works or works that do not alter the property’s volume, such as changes to internal partitions or systems, as mentioned in Article 6 bis of DPR 380.01.
In conclusion, late CILA is a useful tool for regularising certain types of work, but it does not involve the same level of verification required by double compliance. Its exclusion from this article allows us to explore more complex and nuanced aspects of building regularisation involving a stricter and more structured assessment of compliance with regulations over time.
For these reasons, we will focus on SCIA in amnesty and the building permit in amnesty, both of which involve double compliance in these procedures.
But what does double compliance mean?
Double compliance requires the building work to comply not only with the regulations in force when the work was carried out, but also with current regulations. This dual check ensures that regularised works fully comply with regulatory developments.
Another point to clarify is that none of the topics covered in this article concerns regularisation from a landscape-protection perspective. It is nevertheless useful to remember that the latter plays a fundamental role in preserving the area’s cultural and natural heritage, significantly influencing building practices in areas of particular historical, artistic or environmental interest.
Landscape compatibility ensures that all alterations to the built environment respect the integrity and values of the surrounding landscape, whether natural or man-made. This concept is particularly important in Italy, where the landscape heritage is an essential component of cultural identity and requires careful protection to preserve its beauty and uniqueness for future generations.
However, the complexity and specific nature of the rules concerning landscape compatibility require particular attention and should be addressed separately. To gain a general understanding, it is important to recognise the regulatory framework applicable to landscape compatibility. The Italian Codice dei Beni Culturali e del Paesaggio (Cultural Heritage and Landscape Code), pursuant to Legislative Decree 42/2004, is the main source of legislation in this area.
Anyone wishing to explore landscape compatibility further can use the Cultural Heritage and Landscape Code as an essential guide to the applicable rules. Consulting this code, together with support from specialised professionals, can provide the basis for understanding and meeting the requirements for works in landscape-protected areas.
Having made this introduction, let us look specifically at which works require building amnesty.
Which works are subject to amnesty?
Building works that may require amnesty vary from minor property changes, such as enclosing a terrace or creating a small loft, to more significant interventions such as extensions or changes of use. Amnesty is necessary when these works have been carried out without the required permits or in breach of the permits obtained, resulting in non-compliance with current town-planning and building regulations.
Specifically, Articles 36 and 37 of DPR 380/01 state:
Article 36 (L) – Declaration of compliance
1. In the case of works carried out without a building permit, or in breach of it, or without a certified notice of commencement of works in the cases referred to in Article 23, paragraph 01.
Article 37 (L) – Works carried out without or in breach of the certified notice of commencement of works and declaration of compliance
1. The carrying out of building works referred to in Article 22, paragraphs 1 and 2, without or in breach of the certified notice of commencement of works.
However, there are cases in which building amnesty can be avoided even where irregularities conflict with current legislation.
What are these specific cases?
Let us examine them together.
When can building amnesty be avoided?
There are mainly two cases in which building amnesty can be avoided:
Construction tolerance of 2% (as per Article 34-bis of DPR 380/01)
Graphic error
Let us look in detail at what these cases involve and when they can be applied.
Tolerance of 2%: explanation and practical example (Article 34-bis, DPR 380/01)
The concept of tolerance
The tolerance of 2% represents an acceptable threshold for minor measurement discrepancies in building works compared with what is stated in the authorisations. This tolerance was introduced to recognise and regulate the inevitable variations that may occur during the construction of a building work. The relevant legislation is DPR 380/01, which underwent important updates in 2020 concerning construction tolerances.
Changes to the DPR from 2020
From 2020, with reference to Law no. 120, DPR 380/01 broadened the concept of construction tolerance, offering greater flexibility in managing minor variations. These updates clarified the parameters to be met and how tolerances may be applied.
In particular, Article 34 bis of DPR 380/01, concerning construction tolerances, states:
1. Failure to comply with the height, setbacks, volume, covered area or any other parameter of individual property units does not constitute a building violation if it remains within 2 per cent of the measurements specified in the authorisation.
2. Outside the cases referred to in paragraph 1, and only for properties not subject to protection under Legislative Decree 22 January 2004, no. 42, geometric irregularities and minimal changes to building finishes, as well as the different positioning of systems and internal works carried out during works implementing building authorisations, also constitute execution tolerances, provided that they do not breach town-planning and building regulations and do not compromise the property’s usability.
3. The execution tolerances referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 carried out during previous building works, not constituting building violations, are declared by the authorised professional for the purposes of certifying the lawful status of properties, in the forms relating to new applications, notices and building reports or through a specific sworn statement attached to deeds concerning the transfer, creation or dissolution of co-ownership of real rights.
Parameters to be met
The specific parameters covered by the tolerance of 2% include variations in the building’s external dimensions, such as height and volume, areas, both covered and uncovered, and regulatory distances, for example from boundaries or other buildings. These variations must not alter the work’s compliance with current town-planning and building regulations or compromise requirements such as earthquake resistance or safety.
Graphic example
To illustrate the concept of tolerance of 2%, consider the following graphic example of a property plan. It shows how a slight variation in the dimensions of a new build or renovation may fall within the tolerance of 2%, avoiding the need for amnesty, provided that the changes do not negatively affect the building’s safety or functionality.
Graphic error: identification and demonstration
The nature of graphic errors
Graphic errors occur when there is a discrepancy between the design documentation submitted for approval and the actual condition of the completed work. These errors may result from simple oversights in the drawing process or from changes made during the works that were not correctly recorded in the official documentation.
Unlike the case of construction tolerance of 2%, there is no national legislation governing the obvious correction of graphic errors in past authorisations. It is therefore necessary to rely either on specific regional rules, where they exist, or directly on the interpretation of the relevant public administration.
Demonstrating compliance
To demonstrate that a graphic error does not compromise the work’s compliance with current regulations, it is essential to collect and submit detailed documentation. This may include:
Photographic documentation: Photographs of the property when the work was carried out and at later stages can provide concrete evidence of the nature and extent of the alterations. These images must clearly show the areas affected by the graphic errors and demonstrate that the variations do not affect the building’s structural, functional or regulatory compliance.
Comparison between designs and construction: A detailed analysis comparing the original designs with the property’s actual condition can help identify the graphic errors specifically and assess their relevance for regulatory compliance.
Avoiding amnesty: a practical example
Correctly identifying and documenting graphic errors can avoid the need for amnesty.
Practical example: the absence, from the technical drawings of the last authorised project in 87, of a window on the west elevation.
Imagine a flat where the owner wants to carry out a substantial intervention. To do so, they need a professional to check the property’s current condition. However, after inspecting the records, the professional realises that the drawings for the last title submitted to and authorised by the relevant municipality differ from the observed condition: a window is missing from the west elevation. The owner states that the window has always been there and has not been altered over the years. However, the owner’s statement is not enough; the professional must demonstrate that this could be a graphic error involving an inaccurate representation.
What can be done?
To avoid amnesty, the owner or delegated professional can:
Collect photographic documentation: Photographs of the flat before and after the alterations may demonstrate that the window has always been present and has not changed over time.
Prepare a technical report: An authorised professional—a surveyor, engineer or architect—can prepare a report confirming that no changes have been made to the flat since the last title was submitted and authorised.
All the documentation collected and attached to a technical report will serve to certify this compliance to the municipal authority or competent planning office.
If the municipal authority responds positively to the request and confirms the identified graphic error, the ordinary administrative procedure can then be followed, thereby avoiding building amnesty.
Having reviewed the two situations in which building amnesty can be avoided, where neither the construction tolerance of 2% applies nor graphic errors are present, I must proceed with building amnesty.
The first important step is to establish whether this is a declaration of compliance (Article 36 DPR) or SCIA in amnesty (Article 37).
Once this has been done, the next and crucial step is to verify double compliance.
In the next section, we explain this concept in detail, outlining the steps for applying it, to whom it must be demonstrated and the possible implications in terms of penalties, with specific reference to DPR 380/01.
What is double compliance?
As mentioned above, double compliance ensures that any alteration, construction or building intervention complies not only with the town-planning and building regulations in force when it was carried out, but also with current regulations. This principle is crucial to ensure that building works keep pace with regulatory developments and contemporary planning requirements.
How to demonstrate double compliance
Demonstrating double compliance requires a series of actions:
Collecting documentation: It is essential to collect all documentation relating to the building work, including the original building permits, designs and any other document that can demonstrate compliance with the regulations in force when the work was carried out.
Regulatory verification: A detailed regulatory check must compare the provisions applicable when the offence was committed with current provisions, identifying any discrepancies.
Technical report: A qualified professional, such as an engineer or architect, must prepare a technical report certifying the work’s double compliance and explaining in detail how it complies with both past and present rules.
To whom double compliance must be demonstrated
Double compliance must be demonstrated to the competent local authorities, typically the technical office of the municipality where the property is located. This authority will assess the submitted documentation and decide whether the work complies with both regulatory frameworks.
Penalties and costs of regularisation
Financial penalties: what to do and why
Carefully checking the category of the building offence and the appropriate regularisation procedure is essential. It is advisable to carry out a thorough analysis from the start of the amnesty procedure, including challenging the notified building offence. This preventive approach may reduce financial penalties and lead to a faster regularisation process, ensuring that the work complies with current regulations.
The financial penalty calculation varies significantly depending on the procedure used. For minor offences dealt with under Article 37, the financial penalty is based on the increase in the property’s value, ranging from 516 € to 5.164 €. This maximum limit is intended to prevent disparities between penalties for offences of differing seriousness and ensure fair treatment. Article 36 is different.
Let us examine both situations in detail:
Penalty for regularisation under Article 36 of DPR 380/01
The penalty for regularisation under Article 36 of DPR 380/01, concerning a declaration of compliance for a building permit in amnesty, has no fixed amount established nationally for the payment in lieu of penalty, nor does it set a minimum or maximum amount, subject to regional rules. As stated in Article 36, paragraph 2 of DPR 380/01, “The issue of a permit in amnesty is conditional on payment, by way of a payment in lieu of penalty, of double the building contribution or, where it is free of charge by law, an amount equal to that provided for in Article 16.”
This means that the specific amount of the penalty will vary according to the building contribution calculation, which is determined by local legislation and municipal regulations and may depend on factors such as the size of the intervention, the area in which the property is located and the building’s intended use.
Where works have been carried out in partial breach of the original building permit, the payment in lieu of penalty is calculated by reference to the non-compliant part of the work. This approach aims to penalise the extent of the offence proportionately, requiring a higher payment than a simple financial penalty and reflecting the seriousness of the unauthorised work while encouraging compliance with town-planning and building regulations.
It is important to note that the details of the payment-in-lieu calculation and the application of penalties may vary considerably between Italian regions and municipalities because of regional legislation and municipal provisions. To obtain precise information about the costs associated with amnesty under Article 36, it is essential to consult the planning office of the municipality where the property is located and seek advice from a qualified professional, such as an engineer or architect.
Penalty for regularisation under Article 37 of DPR 380/01
For amnesty under Article 37 of DPR 380/01, concerning SCIA in amnesty for minor building offences, the financial penalty is defined more specifically than the payment in lieu of penalty under Article 36. Under Article 37.4, the financial penalty is an amount set by the person responsible for the procedure in relation to the increase in the property’s value assessed by the land agency, or rather _“_equal to twice the increase in the market value of the property resulting from the works and in any event not less than 516 euros.”
Also for the purpose of demonstrating double compliance, the legislation provides the following limits for the financial penalty:
Minimum amount: 516 euros.
Maximum amount: 5.164 euros.
As stated in Article 37, paragraph 4: 4. "Where the work carried out complies with the town-planning and building regulations in force both when the work was carried out and when the application was submitted, the person responsible for the offence or the property owner may obtain amnesty for the work by paying an amount not exceeding 5.164 euros and not less than 516 euros, set by the person responsible for the procedure in relation to the increase in the property’s value assessed by the land agency."
This range of amounts reflects the legislature’s intention to adapt the penalty to the seriousness of the offence and the actual increase in value acquired by the property following the unauthorised work. The specific amount within this range will depend on a case-by-case assessment by the competent authority, which will evaluate the increase in the property’s value based on the alterations made.
The procedure under Article 37.4 is intended for minor offences that do not significantly compromise safety, public health or urban aesthetics. For this reason, the financial penalty is less onerous than the payment in lieu of penalty required for more serious offences covered by Article 36.
To determine the exact financial penalty under Article 37.4, it is essential to consult the relevant municipal planning office and, if necessary, seek advice from building and planning professionals who can accurately assess the increase in the property’s value and guide the owner or person responsible for the offence through the amnesty process.
Final thoughts
Importance of prevention: The best approach is always to prevent the need for amnesty by acting knowingly and respecting regulations from the earliest stages of any building project.
Role of professionals: The importance of relying on qualified technicians and professionals cannot be overstated. Their expertise is essential for successfully navigating regulatory complexity and ensuring that works are compliant and safe.
Regulatory developments: The regulatory context for building and town planning is constantly evolving. Keeping up to date with legislation and administrative practices is essential for managing property effectively.
Revolutionise building amnesty management with our app
When regularising building works, documentation and continuous monitoring of the works are key steps. Recognising the importance of these aspects, our digital app is an essential tool for anyone navigating the complex building amnesty process.
Features and benefits of our app:
Works monitoring: Our app lets you track progress in real time, providing a clear and up-to-date overview of the site’s status.
Photographic documentation: With integrated photographic documentation, you can capture and archive detailed images of the site at different stages of the works.
Site inspection reports: Creating and managing site inspection reports becomes simple and immediate, allowing every technical visit to be documented accurately. These reports are essential for certifying the compliance of ongoing works and recording checks carried out by the competent authorities or appointed professionals.
Revolutionise your building amnesty management with MELA!
For surveyors, architects, engineers, property owners and construction professionals facing the challenges of building amnesty, our app is the ideal solution for optimising works management. We invite everyone interested to explore its potential and discover how it can transform the management of your construction projects.
Download the MELA app and start your free trial!