Practical guide to bills of quantities and tender evaluation

After completing an academic course, people often have only a limited understanding of what a bill of quantities and estimate really means. Since it is an integral part of a technician’s work, it is important to understand how it is prepared, what information it must contain and, above all, which procedures should be followed to produce a good document. In this article, we present a practical example because we believe this is the best way to understand and absorb all the important information in the shortest possible time.

Practical example and guide to preparing a bill of quantities

Contents:

Introduction to the bill of quantities and estimate

In the broad construction sector, one of the most crucial stages is preparing a bill of quantities and estimate. This tool goes beyond simple quantification, representing the process of assigning an economic value to each individual activity involved in a construction project. In this article, we will explore every aspect of this process using a practical case of an apartment renovation.

But first, let us look at what is meant by a bill of quantities and estimate.

What is a bill of quantities and estimate?

Before looking at the practical details, it is essential to fully understand the meaning of a bill of quantities and estimate. We have already covered the explanation of the bill of quantities, but for anyone who is still unclear, a bill of quantities and estimate is a tool that goes beyond mere quantification. It is the process of assigning an economic value to every activity involved in a construction project. Every activity, from demolition to construction, must be described and quantified in detail. This process is essential for providing the client with an accurate estimate of the total project costs.

Through the bill of quantities and estimate, the client can plan the investment required to complete the work using a realistic estimate.

But what aims does this article have?

Aim of this guide

This guide provides a complete and detailed resource on how to prepare a bill of quantities and estimate, using a practical example to guide readers through the process. The ultimate aim is to enable users to gain an in-depth understanding of what preparing a bill of quantities involves, including the necessary information and the contribution that design software can make. It also aims to provide practical advice on how to evaluate contractors’ offers effectively, thereby contributing to the success of construction projects.

Before looking at how to prepare a bill of quantities and estimate in practice, let us clarify its specific purpose.

What is the purpose of a BILL OF QUANTITIES AND ESTIMATE?

The main purpose of a bill of quantities and estimate is to provide a detailed and accurate assessment of the costs associated with a construction project. By quantifying and estimating the cost of all the required work and materials, it enables the client to define the project’s overall budget.

Having clarified these points, let us look in practice at what this document must contain and how it is prepared.

What does a bill of quantities and estimate contain?

The first section of the bill of quantities and estimate is dedicated to identification data, which is crucial. The first page should always include information about the people involved and project details. This information provides immediate context and makes the project easier to understand from the document’s cover page.

Identification data of the people involved

At this stage, we must include information about the designer, the works director (if different from the designer) and the client.

The designer is central to delivering a construction project. In the bill of quantities, the name and contact details of the professional responsible for planning the work must be clearly stated. This establishes the project’s technical responsibility.

The other person involved is the client, namely the person commissioning the work. In the bill of quantities, it is essential to state the client’s first and last name, also to avoid confusion and misunderstandings.

Project description

Another important item to include on the first page is an accurate description of the project on which the entire document will be based. In addition to indicating the type of work—renovation, new construction and so on—it is essential to include specific information about the building and its location.

Example first page_bill of quantities and estimate

The section containing identification data is the foundation for understanding the entire project.

In the rest of this guide, we will explore the next stages of the process in detail, using a real apartment renovation case.

After carefully completing the first page of our bill of quantities, we can continue with the other sections of the document: the list of works, measurements (dimensions and quantities), and details of unit and total prices.

List of works (identification code and work description)

One of the central elements of a bill of quantities is the detailed list of works planned for the project. Each item should be clearly defined and described, indicating the materials to be used and the method of execution. All works must be listed in the correct order, following the chronological order in which they are actually carried out on site. These items must describe in detail how the work is performed. For example: how will demolition be carried out? By hand or using mechanical equipment?

This is important because it affects the price.

To clarify what it means to list works chronologically, we will first identify the walls to be demolished, then those to be rebuilt and finally any transport to landfill, the assistance required for services, windows and doors, finishes and anything else.

Each category can in turn be divided into subcategories, as mentioned above. If demolition is carried out, the subcategory will identify the method used, whether by hand or with mechanical equipment.

In summary, this section must contain the categories of work to be carried out, which vary according to the project.

Measurements (dimensions and quantities)

This section determines the extent of the planned work precisely. It must include the specific quantities of materials and labour required for each work item. Units of measurement must be clearly defined to avoid ambiguity.

An important tip when quantifying the materials required during construction is always to allow for 10% extra compared with the quantity specified in the project. This parameter should not be overlooked because, for example, if I need to lay flooring over an area of 70 m^2, I will need to allow for additional tile cuts around edges and corners. Increasing the required flooring quantity by 10% is therefore useful and essential.

Price list (unit and total amounts)

In this final section, in the last column on the right of the bill of quantities, the costs associated with each work item and the materials planned for the construction project are detailed. This list provides a complete economic assessment, making it possible to determine the project’s total cost.

Once the works and quantities have been established, we can proceed in different ways:

-Refer to the regional price list, which identifies work items and includes their prices. If we have included work not listed in the price list, we must carry out a price analysis.

-For a private building project, I can choose to leave the price fields blank and send the document to several contractors, who will prepare their quotations and provide a price for each item of work. This allows me to assess the best offer later.

At this point, to make the preparation process more tangible, let us examine a practical case study: the renovation of an apartment.

We will analyse the main items in the bill, showing how each stage is described in detail.

Case study of a bill of quantities: renovation example

Let us take the example of a private apartment renovation project, in which the client wants to carry out the following work:

  • Demolish a partition wall
  • Replace the electrical system
  • Replace all flooring
  • Change the wall coverings
  • Create some suspended ceilings
  • Replace the windows and doors

After carefully completing the first page of the bill of quantities and estimate, entering the details of the appointed technician, the client and the building work with its location, we can prepare the various sections that make up the document.

First, we will divide the different project stages, because the work requested by the client requires both demolition or removal and new construction.

We therefore divide the project into 3 main stages:

  1. Preliminary stage
  2. Construction stage
  3. Final stage

How to enter the list of works

As seen above, the first section concerns the works. Here, I must enter the work identification code and its detailed description. Remember that the works must be entered chronologically, starting with the preliminary demolition and removal stage, followed by construction and finally the stage covering suspended ceilings, windows and doors, finishes and other work in this example.

At this point, if you are not experienced in preparing bills of quantities, you may wonder how these works should be entered and where to find their codes.

The answer is that these details can vary from region to region, depending on where the building project is being carried out. Official regional price lists provide a standard guide for identifying work items; they can be found online and are regularly updated.

In our case, we refer to the Liguria region and will therefore consult that region’s price list.

*A brief note is needed. You may be wondering what to do if you need to measure a specific, bespoke item of work that is not included in the relevant price list.

There are two possible approaches:

1-In this specific case, our bill of quantities and estimate is for private work, so it will be sent to several contractors, who will prepare quotations and price all the work we have requested.

2-In other cases, a price analysis must be carried out to find the correct value. However, this article does not focus on that topic, which deserves proper attention, and we will discuss it later. For now, if you would like to explore this subject, here is an article on price analysis.

Let us continue with our example and see it in practice:

The initial section of our bill begins with demolition. We detail the demolition of the relevant masonry, clearly identifying which walls are to be demolished.

The work identification code must be entered next to the description, as follows:

We will follow the same procedure for every work item, moving from the first demolition and removal stage through all the previously mentioned works until reaching the final stage.

How to enter measurements and quantities

As mentioned above, in this section we associate each work item with the specific quantities of materials and labour required. For example, taking the first demolition case, we indicate the amount of masonry to be demolished in square metres, as follows:

To quantify the work required, it is essential to use BIM (Building Information Modeling) design software.

How to enter prices

Finally, there is the work section, which we can either leave blank—only in the case of a private project—if we want to obtain quotations from several contractors, or enter the unit price shown in the price list for the relevant work item and multiply it by the quantity to obtain a total amount.

The final sum of the total amounts will provide an estimate of the costs for the entire construction project.

The importance of using software to prepare a bill of quantities and estimate

The importance of BIM (Building Information Modeling)

Adopting this technology modernises and simplifies the preparation of a bill of quantities because it provides a detailed view and efficient management of information.

Using two-dimensional software tools would take much longer to calculate quantities.

BIM is instead an advanced design approach that integrates all project information into a three-dimensional digital model. This model includes not only the geometry of the elements, but also essential data such as materials, quantities and relationships between components.

Using BIM software such as Revit, Archicad and other equivalent tools therefore offers many benefits when preparing a bill of quantities, especially for quantification and dimensions.

How can BIM help us extract the quantities for our construction project?

We begin by creating a BIM model of the apartment being renovated. We add the walls, floors, services and every other element involved in the project. Naturally, there will be an existing and a proposed stage, from which we can identify the changes made to the project. By creating suitable schedules, this digital model becomes the basis for automatically extracting the quantities needed for the bill of quantities in connection with the planned work.

Another advantage of using BIM software to manage quantities is that, when we modify the project, all information is interconnected, making it easier to update and manage changes.

Software for managing and preparing a bill of quantities and estimate

Once we have generated the schedules in BIM, we can import them directly into software designed specifically for preparing a bill of quantities. These programmes translate BIM information into measurable quantities.

We have now reached the end of this article. So far, we have seen what a bill of quantities and estimate is, what information it must contain, how it is prepared through a practical example and which software can support its preparation.

Once our bill is complete, if we receive several quotations from contractors, you may want some advice on how to assess the best offer.

Choosing the best bill of quantities and evaluating offers

Once we have obtained each contractor’s prices, in the case of private work, we must carefully assess the offers submitted. In this final section, we will explore the key steps guiding this decision.

Detailed analysis and comparison of offers

At this stage, the appointed technician and the client must carefully examine each financial offer, checking that it contains detailed prices for all the work. One useful tip is to keep the regional price list available for price comparison.

It is then useful to create a clear summary of the costs presented in each offer, divided by work category. This provides a quicker and more detailed overview.

If some contractors propose variations or changes to the bill of quantities and estimate, carefully assess their financial and time impacts. Also consider whether these variations bring significant benefits to the project.

Value for money and timescale planning

Another key aspect is to carefully consider the value for money offered by each contractor. It is also useful to assess the timescales proposed. Careful planning is essential to avoid delays and ensure that delivery deadlines are met.

Final decision

We have reached the final step, where all aspects of the offers will be examined and appropriate decisions made. At this stage, it may sometimes be necessary to decide whether to revise certain bill items to optimise costs.

Finally, after completing a full assessment, it is time to make a decision. A contractor must be selected and the decision communicated clearly.

How the Mela app can help prepare a bill of quantities and estimate

Mela supports both the Works Director and the contractor carrying out the work by recording site production and monitoring progress in relation to the bill of quantities.

The app allows each party involved in the project to record daily production and classify it according to the bill-of-quantities items. Here is how:

  1. Create an accounting section dedicated to the bill of quantities.

  2. Enter individual work items without specifying their unit cost. This approach focuses on measurements to make it easier to prepare the measurement book and SAL.

  3. The site manager reports daily site production in a dedicated task shared with the Works Director. This is managed using Mela’s Accounting function.

  4. Using captions and tags, the site manager indicates the specific location of the work (floor, room, apartment, etc.).

  5. The site manager also records any variations from the bill of quantities and identifies them with suitable tags so that they are clear and not overlooked.

  6. With one click, the site manager and Works Director obtain the SAL ready and shared.

In this way, Mela simplifies the process of recording and monitoring work progress based on the bill of quantities.

Try Mela for freeRequest a demo

Download Mela

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Written byChiara Bussani