Example tender documentation: scoring points through digitalisation

In tenders applying the most economically advantageous tender criterion, price cannot account for more than 30% of the final score. What matters instead is a mix of factors, including service delivery, information exchange between the Works Supervisor and the RUP, the use of innovative management solutions, and transparency. Here is how digitalisation can provide the competitive advantage needed to win tenders.

Example tender documentation

The most economically advantageous tender criterion is increasingly used in tender award procedures. In this case, the public administration explicitly states its interest in assessing not only the price of something, but the relationship between quality and price. When this happens, the rules establish that price cannot account for more than 30% of the final score and that the contracting authority wants to assess other aspects such as:

  • Quality
  • Delivery conditions or service performance
  • Greenhouse gas emissions offsetting
  • Cost of use and maintenance
  • After-sales service and technical support
  • Possession of an EU Ecolabel
  • Other aspects

In short, the public administration wants to be treated like a private client, with particular attention to the effects of its investments on the environment and citizens.

Download an example of documentation to submit with a tender to demonstrate investment in construction-site digitalisation.

To achieve this result, the public administration is also willing to pay a higher price, provided that the relationship between what it receives and the cost is advantageous

It is clear that, to achieve this result in construction, the operating methods used to deliver the service are a key factor. Organisational aspects of the work therefore become very important, such as communication, transparency and traceability, and information symmetry.

Furthermore, RUPs will be called upon to answer for the quality of the work carried out (let us remember that they did not choose the lowest price, precisely in order to obtain quality) in often difficult operating conditions. Imagine the RUP of a large city overseeing many works at the same time: they would like to have a control room like those at NASA, but instead find themselves stuck in traffic.

Can we help them? Will they recognise this help? The answer is yes, but let us look at some practical examples in which those who wrote the tender criteria asked us to provide something more in terms of construction-site management. Our response will be supported by digitalisation.

Tender procedures: documentation examples

Example 1

Type of works

Hydrogeological remediation works

Weight of the economic offer

10%

Weight of digitalisation

21%:

  • 7% BIM
  • 7% safety and project management
  • 7% works management and client relations

Criterion

METHODOLOGICAL FEATURES OF THE OFFER

Description of the criterion

  • Use of actions designed to ensure the completeness and readability of the design documents, including through the use of BIM procedures for partial or total design. Weight in the total score: 7%
  • Methodology for the approach to and methods of studying the organisation of safety in relation to the planned works and the timescale within which they must be carried out. Weight in the total score: 7%
  • Methods for collecting, exchanging and sharing information with the Contracting Authority concerning the project data and design decisions during the design development phase, both in the various settings (service conferences, obtaining opinions, validation, etc.) and through the provision of IT systems for sharing digital documents with the contracting authority. Weight in the total score: 7%

Example 2

Type of works

Maintenance of the sewer network and water-treatment works

Weight of the economic offer

30%

Weight of digitalisation

10%

Criterion

TEAM ORGANISATION AND CONTRACT MANAGEMENT

Description of the criterion

  • The Contracting Authority requires the submission of improvement solutions concerning simpler management of the framework agreement as a whole.
  • The tenderer must describe the methods, resources and skills it undertakes to use in order to enable simpler management of the framework agreement as a whole.
  • The company must submit a management proposal for the framework agreement contract as a whole, indicating the organisation it intends to implement and the relevant professional roles (without naming individuals).
  • The tenderer must also describe in detail the use of its own established management procedures or software that enable simpler management and monitoring of the various active and planned implementing contracts, in order to facilitate interaction between the client and the contractor.
  • With regard to site management, the methods of interaction between the tenderer's various key professional roles must also be described in detail, including an accurate description of the coordination procedures, both within the tenderer's organisation and with the contracting authority.

Example 3

Type of works

Renovation and seismic and systems upgrades

Weight of the economic offer

20%

Weight of digitalisation

5%

Criterion included for improving construction-site management

Organisational solutions

Description of the criterion

The assessment will be carried out in relation to the organisational methodology with which the tenderer intends to carry out the works, in order to optimise their execution and enable the contracting authority to monitor their progress as effectively as possible during execution and testing, through to commissioning of the completed work.

Considerations

Based on the research we carried out, and as can also be seen from the examples above, in tenders using the most economically advantageous tender criterion:

- Price is not the only parameter on which to win the tender; in fact, overall it accounts for between 10% and 30%

- The technical solutions we put forward are the core of the matter

- Digitalisation is a fundamental investment for winning tenders. In particular, we need to focus on

  • BIM
  • Works management
  • Communication and transparency with the client
  • Safety management

As always, our focus is not on BIM or pure safety-related work, which have dedicated digital paths, but on works management, collaboration, transparency and construction-site productivity.

By adopting tools for construction-site digitalisation we fully respond to the requirements expressed by the client and collect several valuable points. Above all, the digital site diary (also required by the decree on works supervision – dm 49/2018) enables us to establish that continuous communication flow with the Works Supervisor and the RUP. We can therefore ensure agility in communication, faster decision-making, traceability and transparency.

So, by investing in straightforward construction-site digitalisation, I can:

Investing in construction-site digitalisation therefore improves your position in tenders. Here you can find an example of documentation that you can download and submit with a tender to explain your digital strategy and how it also benefits the client.

This explanation will help us maximise our score when it comes to works management, site organisation, communication and collaboration with the client

Try Mela for freeRequest a demo

Download Mela

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Written byEmanuele Zamponi