Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director on the Digital Construction Site

Minutes templates and processes for the Works Director using the Locci method implemented in Mela. An effective system for managing and simplifying the complexity of works direction on a construction site.

Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director

Minutes templates and processes for the Works Director. When we think of the Works Director, a thousand minutes immediately come to mind; and the more experienced we become, the more these minutes seem to increase in number and complexity. Each new minute surpasses the previous ones in importance and grandeur, almost drifting towards the baroque of bureaucracy.

As Works Directors, however, we are technical professionals and have always valued clarity and simplicity… but encountering the responsibilities associated with the role tends to frighten us, so we often protect ourselves by adopting the most pompous form of bureaucracy.

Today we want to move away from this drift towards the baroque and approach works direction from an agile, fresh perspective. To do this, we have developed a completely digital method for managing works direction on a construction site. We did so together with Laura Locci, founder of the technical practice La Progetti srl and an experienced Works Director in both the public and private sectors.

To begin our journey, we draw a simplified works-direction process and look at how it is handled using the traditional method and how it changes with a little digital support.

The Locci method templates are available to new platform subscribers, or they can be requested by writing to contact@mela.work.

DOWNLOAD THE simplified process PDF HERE >>

We move through our process with the help of two actors:

  • The Analogue Works Director DL-A

  • The Digital Works Director DL-D

(In the notes at the end of the article, you will find the details and assumptions—conditions/justifications—for this simplified process.)

The simplified process for the Works Director developed in Mela

Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director: the appointment

We have just received an appointment for a new construction site, and the first activities are naturally studying the project, the bill of quantities, the various site actors and the contracts.

DOWNLOAD HERE the simplified Excel template of the Locci method for Mela >>

Analogue Works Director

The DL-A buys a new document folder and starts putting all the papers to hand into it.
In the meantime, they open a project folder on their computer or on the practice server, using a standardised structure (Contracts, permits, photos, etc.).

Digital Works Director

The DL-D buys a new document folder and starts putting all the papers to hand into it.

In the meantime, they open a project folder on their computer or on the practice server, using a standardised structure (Contracts, permits, photos, etc.).
They probably do the same things as the analogue director (it is difficult to abandon paper completely!), with a couple of additional actions that will prove decisive as the work progresses:

  • They have downloaded an app for managing construction-site activities (for example Mela for site management)
  • They have asked the contractor to do the same
  • They have opened the new site in the app and shared it with the company carrying out the works
  • They have uploaded PDFs of the projects, contracts, bill of quantities, etc. to the app, so that they are tracked and always available to them and to the company carrying out the works

Using the 01 template of the Locci methodi for works direction, they record all site actors and their contact details in an orderly way. If these change in future, they will update this section, ensuring a shared contact directory for everyone.

Have you noticed that the digital Works Director also uses the app as a shared archive, ensuring that the documents they check are the same as those available to the company carrying out the works?

If everything is in order, the works begin.

Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director: handover of the works

The handover of the works is one of the fundamental steps we included in our simplified process because without it, it is impossible to establish when and according to which criteria the company carrying out the works must begin. This step should be carried out on every construction site, however small or simple it may be.

The handover of the works takes place in person, on site, with at least 2 actors present: the Works Director and the legal representative of the contracting company or their delegate.

In practice, good practice is to include a third person: the CSE. They too must establish a start point for execution of the works, so we might create synergy by following the handover by the Works Director with the CSE coordination meeting.

The Works Director and the company representative are therefore on site, with the project documentation and contracts available, and check that the operations to be carried out are correct, clear and feasible according to the agreed plan and timetable. The Works Director leads the discussion—not always an easy task—and finally draws up the works handover minutes.

Let us now examine the different steps taken by the Analogue Works Director versus the Digital Works Director

Analogue Works Director

The DL-A brought a pre-completed Word document for the minutes and then printed it (one copy, two copies, depending on their habits). They finish completing the sheet by hand, correct the errors and then sign with a pen. The representative of the company carrying out the works signs afterwards.

They must then return to the office, scan the sheet and send it by email to the company carrying out the works.

Sometimes, to make this operation traceable, they choose PEC: this is the only option available to the DL-A for assigning the document a certain date.

They then take the sheet and file it on paper in the famous binder.

Their work has therefore taken place in 3 moments:

  1. Preparing the document in the office before the meeting
  2. The meeting on site, and the final work in the office to complete the handover
  3. Traceability and correct filing

Digital Works Director

The DL-D takes their smartphone from their pocket, opens the Mela app, enters the 02 template and completes it on site. The minutes are signed by them and by the representative of the company carrying out the works, and the handover is completed. The minutes have been added to the activity—essentially a traceable chat—which they shared with the company carrying out the works, so the minutes are immediately available to both parties.

All their work has taken place at the same time as the actual handover of the works on site.

The minutes also have a date and content guaranteed by the system: neither the date nor the content can be modified or altered by anyone.

Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director: the site diary

Let us remember that in our example the site diary is simplified to recording only the works, how they are carried out and the times at which they were carried out. In short, it becomes a history of the work designed to ensure traceability and quality.

To do this, we imagine it as a genuine diary of the work containing photos, videos and descriptions of the works.

A fundamental part of this diary is the photos, orders and decisions taken, the materials used and the related supporting documentation. But let us see how our 2 actors organise themselves to write their little book.

Analogue Works Director

They have created, in the practice’s cloud space—sometimes on the practice server, and sometimes, even worse, on their own computer—a series of folders for collecting documentation, perhaps with a structure like this:

  • Photos of the work

  • Materials

  • Minutes and orders

The problem with this structure is that each of its parts, independently, does not provide a coherent description of everything that happened—a diary that I can read easily.

For example: a problem with a foundation for which the Works Director carried out an inspection on site. They took photos documenting the problem, sent a service order by email, then received a reply email and related messages from the company carrying out the works, and so on.

None of the folders above, however, can account for the entire problem.

To reconstruct the history of the work, it is therefore always necessary to piece together information from several places. Sometimes, for particularly important clients or especially difficult problems, the DL-A physically creates this diary by combining the photos, minutes and other documents in a single Word document. This work takes a great deal of time, which is often not recognised, even though everyone involved benefits from it.

But let us take a step back in the DL-A’s work and focus on photos and how they are collected and archived. We went to the site and took photos with our mobile phone (or someone sent us photos from the site via WhatsApp). Now we have 2 options:

  • Do nothing. The photos build up on the mobile phone, become mixed up and all start to look alike. One day the phone’s memory will be full: what do we do? Delete the old photos? The following week, inevitably, we need the photo we deleted. If we saved them on WhatsApp, it is even worse: as they age, they disappear by themselves.

  • Transfer the photos from the mobile phone to the site’s photo archive. How?

  1. Connect the mobile phone and download the photos.
  2. Email the photos to myself and then download them.
  3. Copy the photos from the mobile phone to my cloud archive

The important thing is that, after transferring the photos, we rename them; otherwise all the columns look alike, as do the flats and doors.

This very simple activity puts the DL-A under pressure because it actually hides a complex archival task, not because the work is difficult, but because it requires commitment and perseverance.

Digital Works Director

Let us remember that the DL-D created an activity in Mela to manage works direction on the site and shared it with the company carrying out the works. Perfect: this activity is their site diary. But what does it look like?

  • It is structured as a diary of the work that describes the progress of the works as they develop

  • The Works Director and the Site Manager both write in this activity as if they were chatting!

  • In the same way, they exchange photos and videos of the completed works

  • Everything is automatically tracked—who took the photo and when, for example

  • The information is archived automatically and securely

  • The information—texts, photos, minutes, etc.—is easy and intuitive to search

  • The history of how the works were carried out is automatically produced by the Mela platform

It is immediately clear that the digital platform simplifies many of the Works Director’s activities, but here we want to focus on an aspect that is easy to miss at first glance: communication between the Works Director and the site. The Works Director is using a TRACKED chat that creates a secure archive. This allows them to avoid unnecessary copying and pasting between WhatsApp, email, PEC, Word files, etc. They do everything from a single point for communication and information collection.

The main benefit will be seen with the minutes, where analogue means endless rounds of emails that digital removes completely.

Note on materials

Some photos often seen in the DL-D’s site diary concern the materials used for the works, starting with the material delivery note, continuing with the pallets on which it was delivered and ending with a detailed photo of the material itself. After all, it is the Works Director’s responsibility to accept the materials used to carry out the works. It is difficult, however, for the Works Director to be on site to accept every material, but technology helps us.

It is not the Works Director who takes photos of the delivered materials, but the Site Manager who, as we know, participates in the same Mela chat.

In addition, the Works Director writes notes about the materials and also uploads the material booklets in PDF to the chat, collecting complete information and recording the inspection carried out.

Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director: service orders

The problem is simple and familiar to all Works Directors: we must leave a written record of an instruction, requirement or decision given to the company carrying out the works, and for this reason we use a fairly simple communication: a service order. Service orders are an integral part of the site’s history; indeed, they describe decisions and the reasons behind them, especially when correcting aspects or problems that would not otherwise take the right course.

Let us see how our 2 actors proceed.

Analogue Works Director

The DL-A is on site and realises that there is a problem. They call the Site Manager and explain what needs to change: they issue a service order—verbally for the moment.

They then return to the office—perhaps several hours and another couple of sites or meetings have passed—and, to ensure that their order remains recorded, take the Word template for service orders and save a new copy in the site’s minutes folder. They complete it, print it, sign it and send it to the company by email.

It is clear that the DL-A has two problems:

  • The formal document arrives hours late compared with the decision and the substantive act

  • the DL-A has once again had to spend 15 minutes of their time after returning to the office

But that is not all! They wait for a reply to the email, wanting somehow to record that the order was also formally received and had its intended effect. When the reply email arrives, they will save it in the folder as a response to the service order (oops… that folder is starting to become chaotic!).

Digital Works Director

The DL-D is also on site and realises that there is a problem, so they call the Site Manager and explain what needs to change. This time, however, they remain on site for another 5 minutes, take their smartphone, open the Mela app and enter the service order directly in the chat using the 03 template of the Locci method.

They then sign the order directly on the phone and ask the Site Manager to do the same (erm… the Site Manager does not always sign immediately :). Done! They return to the office, print it, send it by email and file it!

The Site Manager will also always inform the DL-D through the chat about how they are applying the instructions, leaving irrefutable evidence that the problem has been resolved.

Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director: suspension and resumption of works minutes

If everything goes well and the works continue without major problems, we do not need these minutes. Sometimes, however, for various reasons we are forced to suspend the works. This happens, for example, in the following cases:

  • Force majeure (weather, Covid in March 2020, etc.)

  • Serious delays or contractual breaches

  • Design variations requiring further procedures (calculations, checks, authorisations…)

In this case, it is important for the Works Director to communicate and record the timing, procedures and reasons for suspending the work: this is why suspension minutes are so important. Let us remember that, during suspensions, both the client and the company carrying out the works often suffer financial losses, placing us in one of the conditions most likely to lead to difficult legal disputes.

We will not go into the process followed by our two Works Directors here, because it is identical to the process followed for a Service Order.

In one case, the process takes place partly on site and then in the office, with extensive use of email as a means of communication; in the other, the process is managed through a chat between the Works Director and the company carrying out the works, where they complete the minutes, collect photos and sign. The same considerations made above apply.

For the DL-D, the templates to use in Mela are:

Minutes and Process Templates for the Works Director: completion-of-works minutes

We have reached the end of our construction site. Or rather, let us first imagine that we need to communicate the completion of the structural works. The analogue Works Director continues with their usual method and applies it to every step: Word, PDF, signature, email, filing, reply, filing.

But when communicating the completion of the structural works to external offices that probably do not have Mela, how does our Digital Works Director manage?

Digital Works Director

They are on site, in the office or, if they wish, on the sofa at home, and must communicate the completion of the structural works. The DL-D accesses Mela—they can also use a computer if they wish—and enters the communication directly in the chat using the 06 template. They sign the communication inside Mela and with one click send the signed communication PDF to anyone concerned. Mela itself generates the signed PDF and makes it available for email, Dropbox or other document-transmission tools.

If the Works Director were to take charge of the works before their completion, they could record this in Mela using the early takeover minutes: 07 template. The method is always the same.

We have finally completed our construction site and can draw some conclusions. The Digital Works Director has 3 main advantages:

  • Minimises the work to be done in the office after returning from the site

  • Remains continuously informed and up to date on the progress of the works thanks to the chat mechanism

  • Collects more information, and the information is easy to read, without having to compile complicated progress reports.

On the other hand, they may face one difficulty: convincing the company carrying out the works to accept the use of a digital tool. It is interesting, however, that in the overwhelming majority of cases the company welcomes this innovation enthusiastically for 2 reasons:

  • The tool allows the company itself to track the site’s history easily and be prepared for possible disputes. The company is no longer merely a basic executor of the work, but itself becomes a guarantor of the work’s quality, greatly reducing the risk of disputes

  • Communicating by email is a huge headache for the company carrying out the works, because email communications often go to the company’s legal representative, while operational decisions are made on site with the Site Manager. This split is one of the most recurring sources of inefficiency in contracting companies.

Reducing this misalignment represents a net gain for the company

Note on the simplified process

As you can see, we have identified this process as simplified because it deliberately ignores all financial management of the work (measurement books and SAL). Purists might object that these documents form part of the site diary, but the character we want to give our site diary is that of a work diary—traceability and quality—rather than an accounting record. To be clear, the Works Director will still have to prepare the measurement books and SALs. We do not analyse them here so as not to enter a bureaucratic trap, linked above all to public contracts and payment management.

Our process is therefore linked to the Technical Direction of the works and, for the sake of simplification, we will assume that this can in some way be addressed independently of the financial bureaucracy of the work.

This is how our simplified process came about! The Works Director suddenly becomes an enthusiast for clarity and simplicity again.

Is our approach legitimate? Yes, considering three main aspects:

  • For the client, the Works Director is above all the champion of quality: the person who guarantees that what I, the client, am buying is done properly, according to the design and the best construction standards

  • Outside public contracts, the SAL and payment process becomes considerably simpler, so we can start by considering simple contracts.

  • In the case of public works, using the simplified approach must be agreed with the RUP, who could, for example, be part of the activity team. The parties can agree on customised minutes according to the RUP’s requirements, specifically to ensure uniform use of the tool.

Note on the digital site diary

As indicated in the Official Gazette in DM 49-2018, and subsequently reinforced several times by the legislature, accounting documents for managing public works must be digitised. Consequently, the site diary, minutes, orders and other documents must also become digital. For more details, we refer you to our article on the digital site diary.

One final point.

It is clear that, in the case of public works, using the simplified approach must be agreed with the RUP, who could, for example, be part of the activity team and with whom the minutes can be customised according to their requirements, specifically to ensure uniform use of the tool.

Try Mela for freeRequest a demo

Download Mela

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Written byLaura Locci